美育学刊2024,Vol.15Issue(1) :110-120.DOI:10.20073/j.cnki.2095-0012.2024.01.014

独幅图与连环画——"图咏本"与"全图本"聊斋"女性篇"插图比较

Single Picture and Comic Picture-A Comparative Study on the Illustrations of"Women's Story"in Strange Tales from a Lonely Studio Between Picture-chanting Edition and Full-picture Edition

麻飘飘 刘相雨
美育学刊2024,Vol.15Issue(1) :110-120.DOI:10.20073/j.cnki.2095-0012.2024.01.014

独幅图与连环画——"图咏本"与"全图本"聊斋"女性篇"插图比较

Single Picture and Comic Picture-A Comparative Study on the Illustrations of"Women's Story"in Strange Tales from a Lonely Studio Between Picture-chanting Edition and Full-picture Edition

麻飘飘 1刘相雨1
扫码查看

作者信息

  • 1. 曲阜师范大学文学院,山东曲阜 273165
  • 折叠

摘要

在明清小说戏曲插图的研究中,学界对绘本插图的研究较为薄弱,对独幅图到连环画性质的多幅图的流变关注不够.在不同版本插图的具体比较方法上,大多为多对多或一对一的比较,缺少一对多的比较.比较"图咏本"独幅与"全图本"多幅《聊斋志异》"女性篇"插图,可以发现,在相同图像主题的呈现上体现出它们对情节律的共同追求.在相同图像主题的不同细节处理中存在"全图本"插图对文本的逃逸现象,"图咏本"与"全图本"插图在构图风格上呈现出文人画与风俗画、简朴与繁华、保守性与灵活性的对比.两个版本插图对不同图像主题的取舍反映了它们的雅俗差异,"图咏本"插图强调情节性,对小说的诠释性强,风格偏雅,适合公共性阅读;"全图本"插图喜艳情,崇尚家庭日常生活与民俗表现,观赏性与娱乐性强,风格偏俗,适合私密性阅读.

Abstract

By comparing the illustrations of"Women's Story"in the illustrated version and the full version of"Strange Tales from a Lonely Studio",it can be discovered that the presentation of the same image theme reflects their common pur-suit of plot law.With regard to the different details of the same image theme,the full-picture edition escapes from the text,and the comparison of literati painting and genre painting,simplicity and prosperity,conservatism and flexibility between the picture-chanting version and the full-picture edition are shown in terms of the composition style.The choice of different im-age themes in the two versions of illustrations reflects their differences in elegance and vulgarity.The illustrations in this book emphasize plot,have strong interpretation of the novel and are elegant in style.In addition,the illustrations in the full-picture edition are erotic,advocating family daily life and folk expression,with strong ornamental entertainment and vulgar style.

关键词

《聊斋志异》/图咏本/全图本/独幅图/连环画

Key words

Strange Tales from a Lonely Studio/picture-chanting edition/full-picture edition/single picture/comic picture

引用本文复制引用

基金项目

教育部人文社会科学研究规划基金一般项目(12YJA751040)

国家社会科学基金(17BZW104)

出版年

2024
美育学刊
杭州师范大学

美育学刊

CHSSCD
影响因子:0.234
ISSN:2095-0012
参考文献量2
段落导航相关论文