首页|灰色关联分析与模糊综合评价在水质评价中的对比应用研究

灰色关联分析与模糊综合评价在水质评价中的对比应用研究

扫码查看
为使水质评价结果更加客观合理,以南昌市地表水质量实测数据为例,选取当地 7 个监测断面为研究对象,加入熵权法计算权重,采用灰色关联分析与模糊综合评价对其水质状况进行评价,并对结果进行对比分析.两种方法得出的结果大致相同,除南矶山水质为Ⅱ级外,其余水质均为Ⅰ级,与单因子评价结果存在较明显的差异.灰色关联分析中数据标准化方式以及水质参数的选择对结果影响较大.模糊综合评价计算较为复杂,模糊综合评价矩阵能直观反映超标污染物,具有现实意义.二者各有特点,应根据实际情况考虑多种因素选择合适的评价方法.
Comparative application study of gray correlation analysis and fuzzy comprehensive evaluation in water quality assessment
In order to make the water quality evaluation results objective and reasonable,this paper takes the data of surface water quality in Nanchang City as the example.We select 7 local monitoring sections as the research object,add the entropy weight method,and use the gray correlation analysis and fuzzy comprehensive evaluation to evaluate the water quality condi-tion,and finally analyze and compare the results.It was found that the results obtained from the two analysis methods were similar.The water quality in Nanjishan is class Ⅱ,and the water quality in other sections is class Ⅰ,which is significantly dif-ferent from the results of single-factor evaluation.In the grey correlation analysis,the way of data standardization and the se-lection of water quality parameters have a greater impact on the evaluation results.The calculation of fuzzy comprehensive e-valuation is more complicated,but the fuzzy comprehensive evaluation matrix can intuitively reflect the exceeding pollutants,which is of practical significance.Both methods have their own characteristics,and researchers should take into consideration a variety of factors to choose the appropriate evaluation method according to the actual situation.

grey correlation analysisfuzzy comprehensive evaluationentropy weight methodwater quality evaluationcom-parative application

周亚奇、冯倩、杨晖、刘祥周、李路雨、章晨辉

展开 >

南昌工程学院水利工程学院,江西南昌 330099

灰色关联分析 模糊综合评价 熵权法 水质评价 对比应用

江西省科技厅项目

20213AAG01012

2024

南昌工程学院学报
南昌工程学院

南昌工程学院学报

影响因子:0.272
ISSN:1006-4869
年,卷(期):2024.43(3)
  • 13