首页|科恩对罗尔斯正义理论的批判与社会主义正义的构想

科恩对罗尔斯正义理论的批判与社会主义正义的构想

扫码查看
分析马克思主义者科恩试图通过批判和超越罗尔斯的正义理论来"拯救正义",发展马克思主义的规范理论.科恩指出,罗尔斯的正义理论存在着"国家与社会"、政治与经济分离的二元性缺陷,并误解了规范原则的属性和对象.科恩严格区分了规范原则与调节规则,强调正义原则不以实践为最终目的,也不以社会基本结构为首要对象.他构想了"国家与社会"相统一的社会主义规范原则,认为它不依赖于外在的政治结构,而是通过道德驱动影响个人日常行为来达成正义社会.科恩对罗尔斯正义理论的批判在理论上有所突破,他所说的"国家与社会"相统一的规范理论和社会主义精神风尚值得重视,但他的理论批判局限于修辞学意义上的澄清,而缺乏对社会现实的关注.
Cohen's Critique of Rawls's Theory of Justice and His Conception of Socialist Justice
G.A.Cohen,an analytical Marxist,sought to"rescue justice"by critiquing and transcending John Rawls's theory of justice,advancing a normative Marxist theory.Cohen argued that Rawls's theory suffered from a dual-istic flaw in separating"state and society"as well as politics and economics,and misinterpreted the nature and scope of normative principles.Cohen strictly distinguished normative principles from regulatory rules,emphasizing that prin-ciples of justice were not ultimately practice-oriented nor were they primarily concerned with the basic structure of soci-ety.He envisioned a socialist normative principle that unified"state and society",which did not rely on external political structures but instead achieved a just society through moral motivation influencing individual daily behavior.While Co-hen's critique of Rawls's theory of justice has made theoretical advances,particularly in his unified normative theory and socialist ethical ethos,it remains largely rhetorical and lacks attention to social realities.

G.A.CohenJohn RawlsNormative PrinciplesJusticeSocialist Justice

陈颖

展开 >

中山大学马克思主义学院(广东广州510275)

科恩 罗尔斯 规范原则 正义 社会主义正义

2024

南开学报(哲学社会科学版)
南开大学

南开学报(哲学社会科学版)

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:0.849
ISSN:1001-4667
年,卷(期):2024.(6)