首页|人口老龄化背景下反年龄歧视的法理证成:从平等原则迈向尊严理论

人口老龄化背景下反年龄歧视的法理证成:从平等原则迈向尊严理论

扫码查看
21世纪是人口老龄化的时代.积极应对人口老龄化,事关国家发展全局,事关亿万百姓福祉.在这一背景下,老年人面临的年龄歧视问题受到越来越多的关注.与其他歧视的形式相比,年龄歧视有诸多独特性,使得仅仅以比较价值为核心内涵的平等原则难以充分证成年龄歧视的违法性.尽管平等与反歧视总是存在密切关联,但平等原则中的终身平等理论和代际平等理论认为,所有基于年龄因素而进行的差别待遇都是公平的,没有必要将年龄纳入法律反歧视的范围.与平等原则不同,尊严理论将年龄歧视的违法性定位在侵犯持续性的权利或利益上,而不管其他人是否同样受到剥夺.因此,尊严这一非比较性的价值理论可以较好地弥补平等原则的不足,从而促进达成反年龄歧视的社会共识以及证成年龄歧视法存在的必要性.以尊严理论为支撑,应当优化当前的法律规范,将年龄明确纳入法定的歧视事由中,并待时机成熟之时制定专门的反年龄歧视法.
The Legal Justification of Against Age Discrimination under the Background of Population Aging:From the Principle of Equality to the Theory of Dignity
The 21st century is an era of population aging.The positive and effective impact on China's population aging is relat-ed to the overall development of the country and the well-being of hundreds of millions of people.In this context,the issue of age discrimination faced by older workers has received increasing attention.Compared with other forms of discrimination,age discrimination has many unique characteristics,which makes it difficult to form the theoretical basis of age discrimination law based solely on the principle of equality with comparative value as its core connotation.Although there is always a close rela-tionship between equality and anti-discrimination,the lifelong equality and intergenerational equality theories in the principle of equality believe that all age based differential treatment is legal and fair,and there is no need to include age in the scope of legal anti-discrimination.Unlike the principle of equality,the dignity theory positions the illegality of age discrimination as a vio-lation of sustained rights or interests,regardless of whether others are equally deprived.Therefore,the non-comparative value the-ory of dignity can effectively compensate for the shortcomings of the principle of equality,thereby better consolidating social con-sensus against age discrimination and confirming the necessity of the existence of age discrimination law.Supported by the theo-ry of dignity,China should optimize its current legal norms,explicitly incorporate age into legal grounds for discrimination,and formulate a special age discrimination law when the time is ripe.

age discriminationlifelong equalityintergenerational equalitydignity theory

王健

展开 >

中南大学 法学院,湖南 长沙 410012

年龄歧视 终身平等 代际平等 人的尊严

教育部哲学社会科学重大课题攻关项目湖南省教育厅青年项目

22JZD00222B0003

2024

宁夏社会科学
宁夏社会科学院

宁夏社会科学

CSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:0.37
ISSN:1002-0292
年,卷(期):2024.(4)