首页|压力型体制与基层政策执行波动——基于J省D镇厕所革命的历时性观察

压力型体制与基层政策执行波动——基于J省D镇厕所革命的历时性观察

扫码查看
新时代全面推进乡村振兴落脚于有效的政策执行,理解并消除基层政策执行波动是实现这一目标的重要议题.本文基于压力型体制这一中国特色的理论视角,通过J省D镇厕所革命案例的过程追踪,尝试阐释基层政策执行波动的生成逻辑.研究发现D镇由于处于压力型体制的末端,自上而下的科层压力、自下而上的社会压力和水平方向竞争压力的多重压力汇聚及其动态变化,促使D镇在厕所革命政策执行中采取了履职型回应、应付型回应、消极型回应、治理型回应等执行策略,导致了政策执行效果时好时坏的波动现象.在此过程中,压力以"催化剂"和"抑制剂"的形象存在,压力型体制的"催化抑制效应"渐次发挥且相互转化,塑造出不同政策执行场景的基层政府执行策略,最终呈现出政策执行波动的实践样态.进一步研究发现,压力型体制"抑制效应"所揭示的农村群众角色具有广阔的可建构空间,能够通过自下而上的社会压力输入实现政策执行的纠偏,修复压力型体制的功能失调.长远来看,需要重视压力型体制"催化抑制效应"的发生条件,促使基层政策执行在一个连续时间谱系内达成均衡.
The Pressurized System and The Fluctuations in Grassroots Policy Execution:A Case Study of the Toilet Revolution of Town D in J Province
The comprehensive promotion of rural revitalization hinges on effective policy implemen-tation.Understanding and mitigating fluctuations in grassroots government policy implementation is piv-otal in achieving this objective.This paper,rooted in the pressurized system characteristic of China,seeks to explicate the logic behind the fluctuations in grassroots policy implementation through a case study of the toilet revolution in Town D in J province.The paper reveals that Town D,situated at the end of the pressurized system,faced multiple pressures—top-down bureaucratic pressures,bottom-up societal pressures,and horizontal competitive pressures—which converges dynamically.This convergence leads to the adoption of diverse implementation strategies,including compliance-oriented responses,coping-oriented responses,passive responses,and governance-oriented responses,resulting in fluctuating policy implementation outcomes,ranging from effective to inadequate,within the toilet rev-olution initiative.Throughout this process,pressure is depicted as both a"catalyst"and an"inhibitor".The"catalytic & inhibitory effect"of the pressurized system gradually unfolds and interconverts,shaping varied implementation strategies adopted by grassroots governments within different policy im-plementation scenarios.Consequently,it culminates in the fluctuating nature of policy implementa-tion.Further examination indicates that the"inhibitory effect"revealed by the pressurized system offers substantial scope for rural communities to exert influence,enabling corrective actions in policy imple-mentation through rural societal pressure.This,in turn,addresses the dysfunctional aspects within the pressurized system.Long-term considerations should focus on recognizing the conditions conducive to the emergence of the"catalytic & inhibitory effect"within the pressurized system,promoting a balanced spectrum of grassroots government policy implementation.

Pressurized systemToilet revolutionGrassroots governmentPolicy implementation fluctuation

栗伊萱、马瑞、毛寿龙

展开 >

中国人民大学公共管理学院,北京,100872

压力型体制 厕所革命 基层政府 政策执行波动

2024

农业经济问题
中国农业经济学会 中国农业科学院农业经济与发展研究所

农业经济问题

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:3.177
ISSN:1000-6389
年,卷(期):2024.(11)