首页|情报失误概念界定问题研究——兼析"Intelligence Failure"的翻译

情报失误概念界定问题研究——兼析"Intelligence Failure"的翻译

扫码查看
[目的/意义]厘清各界对情报失误概念的认识分歧,准确认识和界定情报失误概念的内涵与外延,推动学界在对情报失误的定义上达成共识,为进一步深化情报失误研究提供支撑.[方法/过程]通过对中英文主流文献的梳理,比较分析国内外对情报失误概念的基本认识,并对相关争议性问题予以针对性回应.[结果/结论]将情报失误定义为情报机构在情报生产与分发、反情报以及其他情报活动过程中的差错,更加符合其本质属性.决策者对情报的不当使用更多地属于决策问题,而非情报范畴,因而不宜归为情报失误."Intelligence Failure"不宜译为"情报失察",直译为"情报失败"更为贴切.在能准确关照"Intelligence Failure"与"情报失误"的细微差异的情况下,在一定范围内也可有选择地继续沿用"情报失误"这一译法.
Study on the Definition of Intelligence Failure:Also on the Translation of"Intelligence Failure"
[Purpose/significance]The purpose of this paper is to clarify the differences in the understanding of the concept of intelligence failure and accurately understand and define the connotation and extension of the concept of intelligence failure,pro-motes the academic community to reach a consensus on the definition of intelligence failure and provide support for further deepening the research on intelligence failure.[Method/process]Through combing the mainstream literature in Chinese and English,the au-thor compares and analyzes the basic understanding of the concept of intelligence failure at home and abroad,and explores the rele-vant controversial issues to give a targeted response.[Result/conclusion]Defining intelligence failures as errors made by intelli-gence agencies in the course of intelligence production and distribution,counterintelligence,and other intelligence activity opera-tions is more consistent with its essential nature.The inappropriate use of intelligence by decision-makers is more a matter of deci-sion-making than intelligence,and thus should not be categorized as an intelligence failure.The term intelligence failure should not be translated as intelligence oversight,but rather as failure of intelligence,which is more appropriate.In the case of accurately ca-ring for the subtle difference between intelligence failure and intelligence error,the translation intelligence failure may also be used selectively to a certain extent.

intelligence errorpolicy makersintelligence agencyintelligence oversightintelligence failure

汪明敏

展开 >

信息工程大学,河南 郑州 450001

情报失误 决策者 情报机构 情报失察 情报失败

2025

情报理论与实践
中国国防科学技术信息学会 中国兵器工业第二一零研究所

情报理论与实践

北大核心
影响因子:1.302
ISSN:1000-7490
年,卷(期):2025.48(1)