首页|论认罪认罚制度中从宽的确定性——以主客观分层理论为视角

论认罪认罚制度中从宽的确定性——以主客观分层理论为视角

扫码查看
认罪认罚制度中"从宽结果""从宽因素""从宽评价主体"等因素具有特殊性.这些特殊性使得"从宽"的确定性问题需要特别予以关注和澄清.从法律文本来看,"从宽"具有不确定性.以主客观分层理论为视角,即在区分主观层面(评价)与客观层面(结果)基础上,就主观层面的确定性而言,认罪认罚"应当从宽",只不过,在客观层面的确定性上,它可能表现出一种"未必从宽"之样貌.对认罪认罚制度中"可以"从宽的规定,应按照上述"主观层面应当从宽,客观层面未必从宽"的理论逻辑来理解和适用,而不应简单地理解为"可以从宽,也可以不从宽".
On the Certainty of Leniency in the System of Pleading Guilty and Accepting Punishment——From the Perspective of Subjective and Objective Stratification Theory
In the system of pleading guilty and accepting punishment,there are some special characteristics of"leniency results","leniency factors"and"subject of leniency evaluation".Due to those characteristics,the"certainty"of"leniency"needs special attention and clarification.From the perspective of the legal text,"leniency"result is uncer-tain.And theoretical interpretations of the legal text are diverse.From the perspective of subjective and objective strati-fication theory,in other words,on the basis of the distinction between the subjective respect(evaluation)and the ob-jective respect(results),the result of pleading guilty and accepting punishment"should be lenient"on the subjective respect of certainty,only it may show a"may not be lenient"appearance on the objective respect of certainty.The pro-visions that it"may"be lenient in pleading guilty and accepting punishment system should be understood and applied in accordance with the above theoretical logic that"the subjective respect should be lenient,and the objective respect may not be lenient",rather than simply understood in the logic that it"may be lenient,or may not be lenient".

pleading guilty and accepting punishmentleniencysubjective leniencyobjective leniency

林志毅

展开 >

华南理工大学法学院

认罪认罚 从宽 主观从宽 客观从宽

四川省高等人文社会科学重点研究基地四川警察执法研究中心资助项目

JCZFZD2301

2024

四川警察学院学报
四川警察学院

四川警察学院学报

影响因子:0.222
ISSN:1674-5612
年,卷(期):2024.36(2)
  • 16