首页|区块链证据规则体系化的三重逻辑及其制度展开

区块链证据规则体系化的三重逻辑及其制度展开

The Triple Logic of the Systematization of Blockchain Evidence Rules and Its System Development

扫码查看
虽然《人民法院在线诉讼规则》以四个"专条"对区块链证据的审查认定规则做了初步规范,但如何形成裁判者主观上敢于认定、客观上可以准确认定区块链证据,同时能够实质性保障当事人诉讼权利的系统性制度,依然值得深思.从科技融入司法的现实动因以及理论诉求来看,数字时代背景下的区块链证据规则至少要考虑以下三种具有层次递进性的逻辑:一是基于区块链信任机制的真实保障逻辑,二是基于科学认知区块链技术特征的差别对待逻辑,三是基于数字正当程序要求的权利保障逻辑.基于这三重逻辑,可以体系化地构建区块链证据真实性推定规则,准确把握技术原理设定区块链证据审查认定规范,保障当事人实质性诉讼权利的制度规范.未来依然可以按照三重理论逻辑推进在线诉讼区块链证据规则的体系化.
Although the People's Court Online Litigation Rules preliminarily regulated the review and identifica-tion rules of blockchain evidence with four special articles,how to establish a systematic framework that ena-bles judges to subjectively dare to make determinations,objectively accurately identify blockchain evidence,and at the same time effectively safeguard the litigants'right to litigation,is still worth contemplating.From the perspective of the actual motivation and theoretical demands of the integration of science and technology into the judiciary,the blockchain evidence rules in the digital age must consider at least the following three levels of progressive logic,namely the real guarantee logic based on the blockchain trust mechanism,the logic of differential treatment based on scientific cognition of the technical characteristics of the blockchain,and the logic of rights protection based on the requirements of digital due process.Based on this triple logic,it is pos-sible to systematically construct rules for the presumption of the authenticity of blockchain evidence,accu-rately grasp the technical principles,set blockchain evidence review and identification standards,and protect the parties'substantive litigation rights.In the future,it is still possible to advance the systematic develop-ment of blockchain evidence rules for online litigation based on the triple theory logic.

段陆平

展开 >

广州大学法学院

区块链证据 《人民法院在线诉讼规则》 数字信任 真实性推定规则 数字正当程序

四川省哲学社会科学重点研究基地纠纷解决与司法改革研究中心2020-2021年度项目广州市社科规划一般项目

2021DJKT1a12023GZYB71

2024

四川师范大学学报(社会科学版)
四川师范大学

四川师范大学学报(社会科学版)

CSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:0.64
ISSN:1000-5315
年,卷(期):2024.51(1)
  • 22