首页|市场经济秩序:经济刑法的保护法益

市场经济秩序:经济刑法的保护法益

扫码查看
经济刑法的保护法益问题,是经济刑法体系建构的重大理论与实践问题。经济刑法的保护法益需要结合经济刑法产生的背景进行分析。无论是经济自由还是经济利益的法益定位,实际上都反映了以个人自由和个人利益为中心的法益一元论立场。在现代社会,个人自由和个人利益为中心的法益一元论已经式微。经济刑法保护的是集体法益,其内容并非单纯的经济自由或者经济利益,而是市场经济秩序的维护。市场经济秩序与个人的经济自由和经济利益并不对立,而是相互统一与彼此支持的。或者说,市场经济秩序是个人在经济活动中实现自由和利益必不可少的外部条件。因此,对市场经济秩序的保护内在地包含了对个人经济自由和经济利益的保护。作为集体法益的市场经济秩序,虽然在形式上具有抽象性,但其同样具有可损性,可以被具体地损害,因而能够成为经济刑法适格的保护法益。为了实现对市场经济秩序的法益保护,立法对经济犯罪的规制,关注的是犯罪过程要素,危险犯、累积犯等行为主义的设罪模式具有正当性。不过,为了防止可罚界限过度向前挪移,需要明确通过刑法对集体法益进行保护的从属性,适当限制危险犯、累积犯的处罚范围。在司法实践中,经济刑法的保护法益可以发挥穿透式实质认定的作用。在行为没有侵害市场经济秩序时,应发挥法益的出罪功能。
Market Economic Order:The Protection of Legal Interests in Economic Criminal Law
The legal interests in economic criminal law represent a significant theoretical and practical issue in the construction of the economic criminal law system.In recent years,there has been a divergence of opinion within the theoretical community with regard to the legal interests in economic criminal law.In order to gain a full understanding of the protection of legal interests in economic criminal law,it is necessary to analyze this in combination with the background of its emergence.The legal interests positioning of both economic freedom and economic interests effectively reflect a monistic legal interests view that is centered on individual freedom and personal interests.In contemporary society,the monism of legal interests,which is centered on individual freedom and personal interests,has diminished in significance.The field of economic criminal law is concerned with the protection of collective legal interests.Its focus is not on economic freedom or economic interests per se,but rather on the maintenance of market economic order.It can be demonstrated that a market economic order constitutes a protection law interest.Firstly,the development and prosperity of the economy are contingent upon the existence of a stable and sound economic order.The realization of economic freedom and the fulfillment of economic interests are contingent upon the institutional guarantee of economic order.The utilization of criminal law for the purpose of maintaining economic order does not inherently entail a reduction in economic freedom.Economic order and individual economic freedom and development are not mutually exclusive;rather,they are mutually unified and supportive.In other words,economic order is an indispensable external condition for individuals to actualize their economic freedom and pursue their economic interests.In consequence,the legal interest safeguarded by economic criminal law is the market economic order,which inherently encompasses the protection of individual economic freedom and economic interests.Secondly,although the market economy order is a collective legal interest that is inherently abstract,it is nevertheless susceptible to loss and can become a victim object.The conceptualization of economic order as an abstract entity renders its infringement less discernible,and the detrimental impact of a single disruptive action may be relatively minor.However,if left unaddressed,its cumulative impact could precipitate a challenging scenario for the social economy.From the perspective of substantive law,it is not uncommon for criminal law to regard certain systems and the order constructed by the system as the legal interests protected by criminal law.In order to protect legal interests of the market economic order,the legislation on the regulation of economic crime should pay attention to the process of crime.Furthermore,the criminal models of dangerous and cumulative offenses are a legitimate and effective means of addressing these issues.Nevertheless,in order to prevent an excessive shift in the punitive limit,it is also necessary to appropriately limit the scope of punishment for dangerous and cumulative offenses through the subordinate nature of collective legal interest protection in criminal law.In the context of the judiciary,the protection of legal interests by economic criminal law can facilitate the process of substantive identification.It is imperative that the interpretation of the application of criminal law be approached with a clear understanding of its essence and the legal interests it seeks to protect.In instances where the behavior in question does not infringe upon the market economic order,the function of exculpation of legal interests should be invoked.

Economic Criminal LawEconomic crimeLegal interests protectionEconomic orderCollective legal interests

孙国祥

展开 >

南京大学法学院 南京210093

经济刑法 经济犯罪 保护法益 经济秩序 集体法益

2024

山东大学学报(哲学社会科学版)
山东大学

山东大学学报(哲学社会科学版)

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:1.151
ISSN:1001-9839
年,卷(期):2024.(5)