深层链接著作权侵权认定的实证研究——以欧盟法下的新公众标准为视角
An Empirical Study on Determination of Copyright Infringement by Deep Links:A Perspective of the New Public Test in EU Copyright Law
李光宇1
作者信息
- 1. 香港大学 法律学院,香港 999077
- 折叠
摘要
设置深层链接是否构成信息网络传播权直接侵权尚无定论.对信息网络传播行为的判定,国内形成服务器标准和非服务器标准对立之局面,而欧盟法下的新公众标准有截然不同的判定逻辑.基于140个中国法院案例的实证研究揭示:被链作品不侵权的案例中,是否产生"新公众"对于裁判结果有显著影响;被链作品侵权的案件中,裁判理念仍与新公众标准的判定逻辑相符.中国司法实践整体呈现出的裁判规律与新公众标准的隐性契合彰显司法智慧.深层链接是否使得作品向著作权人首次传播所预计的公众范围之外的"新公众"传播应当是判定直接侵权的依据.
Abstract
The issue of whether creating deep links constitutes a direct infringement on the right of communication of works via information networks is still unsolved.The server test and tests opposite to it are proposed by the existing literature.Comparatively,the EU seems to adopt a test based on a fundamentally different logic.However,an empirical study based on 140 cases held by Chinese courts reveals that:As for those linked-to works that do not infringe copyright,the emergence of a new public has a significant impact on decision outcome regarding direct infringement;as for those non-infringing linked-to works,the guiding principle still complies with the logic of the new public test.The implicit consistency with the EU new public test as presented by the Chinese judiciary authorities indicates judicial wisdom and rationality.Therefore,the new public test should serve as the standard for determining an infringement arising from the creation of deep links.
关键词
加框链接/信息网络传播权/新公众标准/服务器标准/直接侵权/法律实证研究Key words
framing link/right of communication of works via information networks/new public test/server test/direct infringement/an empirical legal study引用本文复制引用
出版年
2024
NETL
NSTL
万方数据