首页|穷其源而通其流,举其纲而张其目——木斋《唐前文学源流史》的写作方法

穷其源而通其流,举其纲而张其目——木斋《唐前文学源流史》的写作方法

扫码查看
木斋先生的著作几乎颠覆了"系统完整"性的理念和书写程式,不像以往的文学史著作那样把许多知识点用史的线索串联起来且唯恐有漏,而是主要瞄准"源"和"流"两个关键的部位,穷其源而通其流,举其纲而张其目.最让人震撼的是作者对传统学术成见的破坏与颠覆.如以往文史著作,往往将神话置于开篇处,以神话为中国文学之源.木斋先生则将神话排除文学史系统,以为中国文学起源于神话,是一个时代的"集体误区".以往文学史著作在文体生成的认识上,认为诗歌先于散文产生,故将原始诗歌或《诗经》置于散文兴起之前,木斋先生则认为诗的因素产生于甲骨文的反复记录和书写中,因此散文早于诗歌而产生.以往的文学史著作,将五言乐府如《陌上桑》《上山采蘼芜》《孔雀东南飞》等,以及五言诗经典之作《古诗十九首》都归于汉代文学来论述.木斋先生则将此统统归到曹植与甄后的名下,认为其中一部分诗与曹植、甄后的爱情故事有关,甚至认为苏武、李陵名下的"送行诗",也与曹植、甄后有关,并专设了"曹植五言诗写作源流史"一章.在此一章中,作者以史料钩沉、背景考察、文间寻脉、字里索隐、逻辑推演诸多手段和方式,进行深研细究,最终得出了石破天惊的结论.
Exploring Its Source and Pass Its Flow,Raising Its Program and Expand Its Purpose——Mu Zhai's Writing Method of Tang Qian Wen Xue Yuan Liu Shi
Mu Zhai's masterpiece almost upended the concept and writing style of"systematic completeness"in literary histo-ry,unlike previous literary history works that linked many knowledge points together with a historical thread and feared missing any-thing,but instead targeted the crucial parts of"source"and"flow".Exploring the source to understand the flow,raising the frame-work to expand the details.The most striking thing is the author's destruction and subversion of traditional academic stereotypes.Like previous literary history works,they often placed myths at the beginning to regard them as the source of Chinese literature.Mu Zhai,however,excluded myths from the literary history system and believed that Chinese literature originated from myths,which was a"collective misconception"of an era.Previous literary history works had a misunderstanding about the genesis of literary styles,thinking that poetry came before prose,so they placed the earliest poetry or the Book of Songs before the rise of prose.Mu Zhai,however,believed that poetic elements emerged from the repeated recording and writing of the Oracle Bone Script,so prose came before poetry.Previous literary history works had classified the Wu Yan Yue Fu poetry such as"Mo Shang Shang""Shang Shan Cai Mi Wu""Kong Que Dong Nan Fei"and"Gu Shi Shi Jiu Shou"as belonging to Han Dynasty literature.Mu Zhai,however,attributed all of them to Cao Zhi and Zhenhou's names.He believed that some of the poems were related to the love story between Cao Zhi and Zhenhou,and even believed that the"Farewell Poetry"attributed to Su Wu and Li Ling was also related to Cao Zhi and Zhenhou.He dedicated a chapter to"Cao Zhi Wu Yan Shi Xie Zuo Yuan Liu Shi".In this chapter,the author used numerous means and methods such as historical research,background investigation,textual search,word-by-word analysis,logical deduction,etc.to conduct in-depth research and analysis,ultimately reaching a groundbreaking conclusion.

Mu Zhaihistory of Chinese literaturewriting method

刘毓庆

展开 >

山西大学国学院,山西 太原 030006

木斋 中国文学史 写作方法

2024

山西大同大学学报(社会科学版)
山西大同大学

山西大同大学学报(社会科学版)

影响因子:0.166
ISSN:1674-0882
年,卷(期):2024.38(6)