首页|"屈原赋二十五篇"到刘向《楚辞》成书的"聚合之势"考论——兼说今本《楚辞》篇次的来源之二

"屈原赋二十五篇"到刘向《楚辞》成书的"聚合之势"考论——兼说今本《楚辞》篇次的来源之二

扫码查看
从屈原《离骚》化用自己《抽思》《涉江》《天问》《远游》《思美人》《惜往日》诸篇,以及宋玉、贾谊、司马迁、东方朔或化用或论及屈作分别达今存七卷中之五卷、六卷、四卷、五卷等情况看,一个共 25 篇的"屈原集"很可能早已存在,甚至就是屈原自己所编.再从司马迁《屈原列传》、东方朔《七谏》看,今存《楚辞》中宋玉等人的拟屈之作也已围绕着屈原及其作品形成了一个"关系网".因此,刘向编《楚辞》应是基于这样一个"屈原集"加"关系网",合并、落实、调适而成的.就其"调适"而言,他主要受了司马迁影响,一是依循"时间"标准排列篇次,二是依据"悲其志"主旨进行再选拔;此外,他还引入了"代屈原设言"的写作标准.
A Study of"Trend of Combination"from"25 Poems by Qu Yuan"to Liu Xiang's Compilation of Chu Ci:Also on the Second Source of Its Current Edition
Tang Bingzheng posits that the compilation of Chu Ci spanned five stages,as has shifted the research focus of this topic to the period from Song Yu to Liu An,contributing significantly to the research direction,albeit with a conclusion that merits further discussion.The incorporation of his own works,including Chou Si,She Jiang,Tian Wen,Yuan You,Si Mei Ren,Xi Wang Ri and Li Sao by Qu Yuan himself,as well as the frequent citation and comments on his works by Song Yu,Jia Yi,Sima Qian,and Dongfang Shuo,which are distributed across five,six,four,and five volumes respectively out of the seven surviving volumes,suggests the early existence of a"Collection of Qu Yuan"including 25 poems,potentially compiled by Qu Yuan himself.Furthermore,according to Sima Qian's Qu Yuan Lie Zhuan and Dongfang Shuo's Qi Jian,it is evident that the imitation poems by Song Yu and others in the extant Chu Ci have formed an intricate"network of relationships"centered on Qu Yuan and his oeuvre.Consequently,Liu Xiang's compilation of Chu Ci is likely grounded in this"Collection of Qu Yuan"and its associated"network of relationships",undergoing a process of integration,refinement and adjustment.In terms of adjustment,Liu Xiang was primarily influenced by Sima Qian,adhering to two key principles in handling the texts:chronological arrangement and reselection according to the theme of"mourning his aspirations".In addition,he also introduced the writing standard of"speaking on behalf of Qu Yuan".

Qu YuanChu CiSima QianLiu Xiang

谢天鹏

展开 >

湖南理工学院 中国语言文学学院,湖南 岳阳 414006

屈原 《楚辞》 司马迁 刘向

2025

三峡大学学报(人文社会科学版)
三峡大学

三峡大学学报(人文社会科学版)

影响因子:0.469
ISSN:1672-6219
年,卷(期):2025.47(1)