Comparing live birth rate and cumulative live birth rate of long-acting long protocol in the early follicular and mid-luteal phases
Objective:To compare the live birth rate per transplant cycle and cumulative live birth rate per oocyte retrieval cycle of controlled ovary hyperstimulation using long-acting long protocol in the early follicular and mid-luteal phases in order to explore the advantages and disadvantages of two kinds of pituitary down-regulation protocols.Methods:A retrospective analysis of the patients(a total of 1 969 cycles)with normal ovarian reserve function who underwent IVF-ET in Reproductive Center of Ningbo University Affiliated Women and Children's Hospital from January 2018 to December 2021.According to different ovulation protocols,these patients were grouped into early follicular group(receiving long-acting long protocol in early follicular phase,461 cycles)and luteal phase group(receiving long-acting long protocol in the mid-luteal phase,1 508 cycles).Basic characteristics and clinical outcomes of the two groups were compared.Results:There were no significant differences in basic characteristics of the two controlled ovarian stimulation protocol,such as age,infertility years,body mass index(BMI),anti-Müllerian hormone(AMH)level,and the cause of infertility(P>0.05).The average gonadotropin(Gn)day of the early follicular group was higher than those of the luteal phase group[(11.0±3.3)days vs.(10.6±3.1)days,P<0.01)].The average Gn doses in the early follicular group were lower than those of the luteal phase group[(2 390.9±331.3)U vs.(2 645.5±308.1)U,P<0.01)].There were no significant differences in average number of dominant follicles,the numbers of eggs retrieved and available embryos between the two groups(P>0.05).The average levels of estradiol(E2),LH and progesterone in the peripheral blood of the early follicular group were significantly lower than those in the luteal phase group(P<0.01).There were no significant differences in endometrial thickness on the day of transplantation and the number of transplant embryos between the two groups(P>0.05).The live birth rate in fresh transplant cycle of the early follicular group was lower than that of the luteal phase group,showing no significant difference(44.81% vs.49.34%,P=0.26).In the early follicular group,both the incidence of moderate or severe OHSS and cumulative live birth rate were lower than those of the luteal phase group,showing no significant differences(0.87% vs.1.59%,68.11% vs 70.76%,P>0.05).Conclusions:The clinical outcome of long-acting long protocol in the early follicular phase is similar to that in mid-luteal phase in patients with normal ovarian reserve function.
Controlled ovarian hyperstimulationIVF-ETLive birth rateCumulative live birth rate