首页|侦诉审"互相制约"的冲突与调适

侦诉审"互相制约"的冲突与调适

扫码查看
侦诉审"互相制约"是刑事诉讼的基本原则,包含了侦诉、侦审、诉审三者之间的关系.以审判为中心的诉讼制度改革为侦诉审"互相制约"的重释提供了契机,应摒弃"废除论""修改论"的观点,从"解释论"的角度为侦诉审"互相制约"注入生机."互相制约"有其深厚的权力监督理论渊源,需要厘清其与"互相配合"及检察机关"法律监督"之间的关系.当前,侦诉审"互相制约"存在侦诉之间配合程度较高、诉审分离尚未实现、逆向制约机制尚不健全等现实冲突.在以审判为中心的语境下形成审判制约起诉、起诉制约侦查的逆向制约格局,改变过去"平行式"的制约模式.侦诉审"互相制约"的调适,应当以统一的证明标准健全审判逆向制约方式,以检察引导侦查协调审前阶段的制约关系,明确辩护权制约公权力的独特地位.
The Conflict and Adjustment of Investigation-Prosecution-Trial"Mutual Restriction"
Investigation-prosecution-trial"mutual restriction"is the basic principle of criminal procedure,including the relationship among investigation,investigation and trial.The reform of trial-centered litiga-tion system provides an opportunity to restate the investigation-prosecution-trial"mutual restriction".It is necessary to abandon the viewpoints of"abrogation theory"and"modification theory"and to inject vitali-ty into the investigation-prosecution-trial"mutual restriction"from the angle of"interpretation theory"."Mutual restriction"has its profound theoretical origin of power supervision,and it is necessary to clarify the relationship between"mutual cooperation"and"legal supervision"of procuratorial organs.At pres-ent,there are some practical conflicts such as high degree of cooperation between investigation and prose-cution,the unrealized separation of prosecution and trial,and the imperfect reverse restriction mecha-nism.In the trial-centered context,the reverse restriction pattern of trial restricting prosecution and pros-ecution restricting investigation has been formed,and the previous"parallel"restriction pattern has been changed.To adjust the investigation-prosecution-trial"mutual restriction",it is proposed to perfect the reverse restriction mode of trial with a unified standard of proof,to guide the investigation to coordinate the restriction relationship of pre-trial stage,and to clarify the unique position of the defense right to re-strict public power.

mutual restrictiontrial-centeredpower restriction and supervisionstandard of proofde-fense right

洪刚

展开 >

中国司法大数据研究院社会治理研究中心,北京 100043

互相制约 以审判为中心 权力制约监督 证明标准 辩护权

山西省人民检察院检察理论研究课题

SX2023B24

2024

太原理工大学学报(社会科学版)
太原理工大学

太原理工大学学报(社会科学版)

CHSSCD
影响因子:0.218
ISSN:1009-5837
年,卷(期):2024.42(1)
  • 22