首页|侵犯公民个人信息罪的法益重构

侵犯公民个人信息罪的法益重构

扫码查看
侵犯公民个人信息罪保护法益的确定需要综合个人信息的性质、犯罪构成等因素分析.个人信息的性质是确定保护法益的最重要因素.个人信息的首要属性是人身、财产安全等人体属性,次要属性为社会公共秩序与安全等公共属性.将侵犯公民个人信息罪的保护法益认定为个人法益会忽视个人信息中包含的社会公共安全价值,而认定为超个人法益则会忽视个人信息的个体性这一首要属性.因此,单采个人法益或超个人法益很难全面评价本罪.兼顾个人法益和超个人法益的混合法益说既体现了刑法对自然人个体权益的保护,也体现了对社会公共利益的保护,可以有效评价本罪的保护法益,促进司法适用的规范化,有利 于全方 位保护公民个人信息,排除不当罚的侵犯公民个人信息行为.需要注意的是,混合法益说不是个人法益说和超个人法益说的简单累加,而是在结合两种学说的基础上,进一步结合被侵犯个人信息的性质、数量、场景等具体情况进行个案分析.
The Legal Benefit Reconstruction of the Crime of Infringing Citizens'Personal Information
To determine the protective legal interests of the crime of infringing citizens'personal informa-tion,it is necessary to analyze factors such as the nature of personal information and the constitution of the crime.The primary attributes of personal information are personal attributes,such as personal and property safety;its secondary attributes relate to broader concerns,including social order and public se-curity.To regard the protective legal interests of the crime of infringing citizens'personal information as personal legal interests will neglect the social public security value contained in the personal information,and to regard it as super-personal legal interests will neglect the primary attribute of personal nature of personal information.Therefore,simply adopting either personal or super-personal legal interests alone fails to comprehensively assess this crime.The mixed legal interest theory,which considers both personal and super-personal legal interests,can effectively evaluate the protective legal interests,and promote the standardization of judicial application.Moreover,it contributes to protect citizens'personal information in all aspects,and to exclude the infringement of citizens'personal information by undue punishment.The part of personal legal interests in mixed legal interest theory embodies the protection of human rights and interests in criminal law,while the part of super-personal legal interests embodies the protection of social public interests.The mixed legal interest theory is not a simple accumulation of personal legal in-terest and super-personal legal interest;rather,it requires a contextual analysis that considers specific factors such as the nature and quantity of infringed personal information.

protective legal interestspersonal informationmixed legal interestslayered protection

石倩雯

展开 >

北京航空航天大学法学院,北京 100083

保护法益 个人信息 混合法益 分层保护

2024

太原理工大学学报(社会科学版)
太原理工大学

太原理工大学学报(社会科学版)

CHSSCD
影响因子:0.218
ISSN:1009-5837
年,卷(期):2024.42(5)