承认与执行国际体育仲裁院上诉裁决的商事保留问题研究
Study on Commercial Reservations to the Recognition and Enforcement of Appeal Awards of the Court of Arbitration for Sport
王俊晖1
作者信息
摘要
依据《纽约公约》承认与执行国际体育仲裁院上诉裁决可能面临商事保留障碍.同时,我国《体育法》修订后,对体育仲裁与商事仲裁范围进行严格区分,由此,包含经济上的权利义务内容的上诉裁决可能无法得到承认与执行.对此,可借鉴瑞士、美国审判实践中的"金钱价值衡量法"与"商业及财产利益解释法",从明确上诉裁决是否涉及经济上的权利义务出发,确定承认与执行上诉裁决的方案:一般情况下,承认与执行职业体育中产生的上诉裁决;有选择地承认与执行与职业体育或商业活动紧密联系的业余体育上诉裁决;调适"金钱价值衡量法",排除非因经济利益争议而产生的上诉裁决.
Abstract
The recognition and enforcement of Court of Arbitration for Sport appeal awards under the New York Convention may face the obstacle of commer-cial reservation.At the same time,after the revision of China's Sports Law,a strict distinction has been made between the scope of sports arbitration and commer-cial arbitration,thus,the appeal awards containing economic rights and obligations may not be recognized and enforced.In this regard,we can draw on the monetary value method and the commercial and property interest interpretation in Swiss and American trial practice to determine the options for recognising and enforcing ap-peal awards from the perspective of clarifying whether or not the appeal award in-volves economic rights and obligations:generally recognizing and enforcing appeal awards arising in professional sports;selectively recognising and enforcing appeal awards in amateur sports that are closely linked to professional sports or commer-cial activities;and adjusting the monetary value method to exclude appeal awards that do not arise out of disputes over economic interests.
关键词
国际体育仲裁/国际体育仲裁院/上诉裁决/承认与执行/商事保留Key words
international sports arbitration/Court of Arbitration for Sport/ap-peal awards/recognition and enforcement/commercial reservation引用本文复制引用
出版年
2024
NETL
NSTL
万方数据