首页|论高空抛物侵权场合公安机关违反调查职责的赔偿责任

论高空抛物侵权场合公安机关违反调查职责的赔偿责任

扫码查看
《民法典》第1254条第3 款规定了高空抛物侵权场合中"依法及时调查"属于公安机关的法定职责,违反该职责所引发的法律后果在《民法典》未作规定的情况下应回到一般法,即在《人民警察法》中予以确定.其中,相应的损害赔偿责任可经由《人民警察法》第50 条引致到《国家赔偿法》中进行认定.当公安机关违反调查职责导致真正侵权人难以确定时,受害人、可能加害的建筑物使用人遭受的纯粹经济损失可以纳入《国家赔偿法》的调整范围.当符合《国家赔偿法》第 2 条规定的构成要件时,受害人、可能加害的建筑物使用人可以向违反调查职责的公安机关主张国家赔偿.受违反安全保障义务的建筑物管理人应承担补充责任的影响,可能加害的建筑物使用人主张的赔偿责任数额与其承担的补偿责任范围相同,受害人主张的赔偿责任数额是其从真正侵权人处获得的赔偿总额与建筑物管理人承担的补充责任数额及可能加害的建筑物使用人承担的补偿责任数额相加之后的差额.
Liability of Public Security Organs for Violation of Investigation Duties in the case of the Tort of Throwing Objects from a Height
Article 1254(3)of the Civil Code stipulates that the police authorities shall"promptly investigate in accordance with the law"on the occasion of throwing objects from a height,which is a legal duty of the police authorities,and the legal consequences of the violation of this duty shall be determined by returning to the People's Police Act,which is the general law of police law,in the absence of any provision in the Civil Code.Among other things,the corresponding liability for damages can be recognized by the State Compensation Law through article 50 of the People's Police Law.In cases where the police authorities have violated their investigative duties in such a way as to make it difficult to identify the real perpetrators of the violations,the purely economic losses suffered by the victims and the users of the building who may have been victimized are covered by article 2 of the State Compensation Law.The amount of liability claimed by the potentially victimized building user is the same as the scope of his/her compensatory liability,subject to the supplementary liability assumed by the building manager who violated the duty of safety and security,and the amount of liability claimed by the victim is the difference between the total amount of compensation that he/she can obtain from the true tortfeasor and the supplementary liability assumed by the building manager and the compensatory liability assumed by the potentially victimized building user.

throwing objects from heightpolice authoritiesinvestigative dutiesstate compensationcompensatory liability

朱晓峰

展开 >

中央财经大学 法学院,北京 100081

高空抛物 公安机关 调查职责 国家赔偿 补偿责任

2024

现代法学
西南政法大学

现代法学

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:2.725
ISSN:1001-2397
年,卷(期):2024.46(4)
  • 1
  • 32