首页|整体不法评价理论:内涵、概念和特色

整体不法评价理论:内涵、概念和特色

扫码查看
刑事不法存在两种评价方案:一是双层不法评价方法,二是整体不法评价方法.整体不法评价理论认为,不法是一个不可分割的整体状态,不法由确立不法的要素和排除不法的要素组成,确立不法的要素是不法的正面构成要件要素,排除不法的要素是不法的负面构成要件要素.对于不法的成立而言,正面构成要素和负面构成要素具有同等重要的不法评价地位,两者缺一不可,缺少了正面构成要素或负面构成要素的行为都不是不法行为.与双层不法评价方法相比,整体不法评价理论在对行为不法的评价标准、评价方法、评价要素、评价范围、评价程序等方面都存在本质区别.全面系统的不法评价机制,既指出了双层不法评价体系存在的缺陷,同时也形成了整体不法评价方法的基本理论特色.
The Theory of Overall Illegal Evaluation:Connotation,Concept and Characteristics
There are two evaluation methods for criminal illegality:one is the dual level evaluation method for illegality,and the other is the overall evaluation method for illegality.The theory of overall illegality evaluation believes that illegality is an indivisible overall state,consisting of elements that establish illegality and elements that exclude illegality.The elements that establish illegality are positive elements of illegality,while the elements that exclude illegality are negative elements of illegality.For the establishment of illegality,both positive and negative elements have equal importance in the evaluation of illegality,and both are indispensable.Acts without positive or negative elements are not illegal acts.Compared with the dual level illegal evaluation method,the overall illegal evaluation theory has essential differences in the evaluation criteria,evaluation methods,evaluation elements,evaluation scope,evaluation procedures,and other aspects of illegal behavior.A comprehensive and systematic illegal evaluation machine.The system not only points out the shortcomings of the dual level illegal evaluation system,but also forms the basic theoretical characteristics of the overall illegal evaluation method.

illegalitythe integral elements of illegalitydouble layer illegal evaluation methodoverall illegal evaluation method

冷必元

展开 >

湖南工业大学法学院

不法 整体不法构成要件 双层不法评价方法 整体不法评价方法

2023

刑法论丛

刑法论丛

ISSN:
年,卷(期):2023.1(1)