首页|论中国传统法典立法技术的发展——以唐明律计亩论罪为中心的考察

论中国传统法典立法技术的发展——以唐明律计亩论罪为中心的考察

扫码查看
中国传统立法沿革表明,其法典立法技术在不断进步,而唐明律计亩论罪量刑方式则较为明显地反映出这种变化.其立法技术沿革模式可以分为两类:一类是侵犯他人田土使用权和所有权的犯罪,罪刑虽然有所改动、整合,但传承关系明显;另一类与土地分配、赋役征派等基本国策相关联,因政策调整,犯罪类型差异大,但其部分刑等设计却随刑罚体系传承下来.计亩论罪与计赃论罪的原理不同,不能简单视为实物计赃,其行用与犯罪不符合盗罪构成有关,也是国家财政方针在法律中的如实反映.唐明两朝计亩论罪呈现出量刑从公私不分到区分官民、刑罚偏轻且具备体系性的鲜明特点.与唐代相较,明代更加重视官有财产保护以及体系内各罪刑罚间的联系,其立法技术更趋完善.
On the Development of Legislative Techniques of Traditional Chinese Legal Codes:A Study on Sentencing Based on the Acreage of Land in Tang and Ming Codes
The evolution of traditional Chinese legislation has witnessed significant advancements in the legislative techniques of legal codes.Among various legal issues,sentencing based on the acreage of land in Tang and Ming Codes has received scant scholar-ly attention in terms of its development.Based on the crimes involved,two different patterns can be discerned.In cases of infringe-ment on land use rights and ownership,the legacy of Tang Codes persisted in Ming Codes,although with modifications and integra-tion in crime classification and punishments.Conversely,crimes related to fundamental national policies such as land distribution,ta-xes,and corvée underwent significant classification changes,with some punishments inherited from previous systems.It is essential to differentiate sentencing based on the acreage of land from sentencing based on the proceeds of crime.The former should not solely be seen as treating only tangible assets as crime proceeds;it is linked to offenses beyond the scope of theft,reflecting national finan-cial strategies within legal boundaries.The evolution of sentencing based on the acreage of land during the Tang and Ming Dynasties demonstrates a clear shift in sentencing principles,from a lack of differentiation between officials and civilians to the introduction of such differentiation.Moreover,punishments became less severe,and legislative approaches became more systematic.Compared to the Tang Dynasty,the Ming Dynasty placed greater emphasis on protecting the property of officials and the interconnectedness among va-rious crimes and punishments within the legal framework,showcasing more refined legislative techniques.

Tang and Ming Codeslegislative techniquessentencing based on the acreage of landsentencing based on the proceeds of crimesentencing

周东平、王舒

展开 >

厦门大学 法学院,福建 厦门 361005

唐明律 立法技术 计亩论罪 计赃论罪 量刑

国家社会科学基金重大项目

23ZDA079

2024

厦门大学学报(哲学社会科学版)
厦门大学

厦门大学学报(哲学社会科学版)

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:0.876
ISSN:0438-0460
年,卷(期):2024.74(3)
  • 46