首页|五四用典之争与现代汉语用典论

五四用典之争与现代汉语用典论

扫码查看
"不用典"是胡适"文学改良"即国语白话文的重要内容.胡适把用典区分为"广义用典"和"狭义用典",他反对的是"狭义用典".胡适认为,用典缺乏创造性,是一种没有才气的表现,在表达上容易导致歧义,导致表义误解.陈独秀赞成胡适"不用典"主张,他主要是从美学即文辞的艺术性角度来提倡不用典的.钱玄同赞成胡适的"不用典"论,他认为白话文的特点是表达直接,通俗易懂,而用典则是与此相违背的.废名主张现代汉语写作应该用典,他认为用典是"高明作者"写作手法,实际上是把用典看作是一种写作修辞技巧而非内容的表达.用典从根本上是语言的问题,既是语言修饰,但更是思想表达,用典即借用陈语来表达,用大家都熟悉的故事来表达,这种表达既是表达自己,更是延续传统,是语言内部自然产生的现象,属于语言使用的正常规律.用典是语言习得的必然结果,绝不是人为的刻意的文字游戏.用典具有美学上的意义,具有强大的逻辑能力.现代汉语写作不仅用古典,还大量用今典和洋典.
The Debate on the Use of Allusions During the May Fourth Movement Period and a Discussion on the Use of Allusions in Modern Chinese
"Avoiding using allusions"was an important aspect of Hu Shi's literary reform,which advoca-ted the use of vernacular Chinese.He distinguished between"broad allusions"and"narrow allusions",and op-posed to the use of"narrow allusions".For him,using allusions was a sign of lack of talent and creativity,and was likely to lead to ambiguities and misunderstandings in expression.Both Chen Duxiu and Qian Xuantong a-greed with him.Chen approached mainly from the aesthetic perspective of the artistic quality of language,while Qian believed that using allusions might damage the directness and lucidity which characterizes vernacular Chi-nese.However,Fei Ming thought differently,arguing that using allusions was a sign of"skilled authors"and viewing allusions as essentially a rhetorical device rather than a means of content expression.Fundamentally,u-sing allusions is a linguistic issue,a means of both rhetorical and expressive purposes.Taking advantage of famil-iar sayings and stories that everyone knows,the use of allusion helps convey the user's thoughts while continue tradition.It is a natural linguistic phenomenon and an inevitable result of language acquisition,rather than an ar-tificial and deliberate word game.Because of its aesthetic and logical functions,it has been widely used in mod-em Chinese writing,whether in the form of classical,contemporary and foreign allusions.

use of allusionsmodem ChineseHu ShiChen DuxiuQian XuantongFei Mingcon-temporary allusionsforeign allusions

高玉

展开 >

浙江师范大学 人文学院,浙江 金华 321004

用典 现代汉语 胡适 陈独秀 钱玄同 废名 今典 洋典

国家社会科学基金重大课题

16ZDA190

2024

学术界
安徽省社会科学界联合会

学术界

CSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:0.411
ISSN:1002-1698
年,卷(期):2024.(7)