首页|我们缘何需要重新审视创造性的政治:危险的欢庆模式

我们缘何需要重新审视创造性的政治:危险的欢庆模式

扫码查看
由于尚未细致检视服务于威权、暴力与歧视实践的创造性①存续过程、策略与产品,我们无法直面下述伦理问题,当沉湎于或抽象或具体情境(如数字文化、人工智能或教育)中的"创造性"而罔顾其政治运作与实际影响时,究竟会发生什么.在阐述此论点之前,本文援引二十余年来与儿童和青少年合作收集的诸多资料,以描摹各种政治或社会层面的创造性.这些证据涉及媒体使用、政治或公民参与以及日常的社会再生产.本文从理论层面阐述儿童和青少年如何借助创造性学习与新旧技术来维持日常生存、参与政治事务并实施行动主义抗争.本文主要讲述三位青少年的生动故事,它们依托2007年至2020年间笔者开展的一系列质性田野调查,包括面对面深度访谈、民族志观察、文本分析和语境及历史分析.这些故事意图挑战与"创造性"及"学习"相关的理论建构背后"缺乏省思的规范性",同时发掘讨论那些因与规范性事实和框架不符而未被正视的创造形式.
Why We Should Take a Second Look at the Politics of Creativity:The Dangers of a Celebratory Mode
At the heart of this article is an ethical contention:By avoiding scrutiny of creativity sustaining processes,strategies and products serving authoritarian,violent or discriminatory practices,we fail to face the ethical question of what happens when we fetishize"creativity"either in the abstract or in particular circumstances(such as in regard to digital culture,AI or educa-tion)without attending to the politics and effects of its deployment.Leading up to this contention,the article draws on evidence from more than two decades of work with children and young people in regard to media use,political or civic participation and contributions to everyday social reproduction to describe a range of political and social creativity.The article theorizes the way children and young people apply creative learning-and technologies old and new-to everyday survival,politics and activist struggle.Generated from a range of qualitative methodological fieldwork carried out between 2007 and 2020,including in-depth face-to-face interviewing,ethnographic observation,textual analysis and contextual,historical analysis,three youth-cen-tered vignettes at the heart of the article offer a necessary provocation around unreflexive normativity when theorizing creativity and learning,problematizing the non-recognition of forms of creativity that do not line up with normative imperatives and frame-works.

creativity and discriminationglobal southsustainabilitydangerous creativitychildren and youthunreflexive normativity

沙昆塔拉·巴纳吉、蔡振华

展开 >

伦敦政治经济学院 媒体与传播学系,英国 伦敦 WC2A 2AE

复旦大学 新闻学院,上海 200433

创造性与歧视 全球南方 可持续性 危险的创造性 儿童与青少年 缺乏省思的规范性

2024

学术探索
云南省社会科学界联合会

学术探索

CHSSCD
影响因子:0.464
ISSN:1006-723X
年,卷(期):2024.(5)
  • 23