首页|中国公司监事义务的独立证成与法律实现

中国公司监事义务的独立证成与法律实现

扫码查看
中国对公司监事义务的安排历来具有非独立性的表征,不仅立法对监事义务和董事义务长期坚持同质假定的立场,监事义务条款在司法实践中也呈现出附随启用的现象.而公司监事义务与董事义务的一贯混同,客观上轻视了监事与董事之间的角色差异,模糊了信义义务的适用场域,也一定程度上造就了监事制度弱效的实践窘境.实质上,中国的公司监事并非公司法信义义务的适格受托人,其并不满足承担信义义务的特定条件.而公司监事义务的独立能够充分发挥义务的强制属性和行为内容的具体指引作用,且监事义务的稳定性和可预期性也使得公司监事义务具有独立的可能.因此,为助益公司监事制度运行的有效实现,监事义务的制度配套适宜采取独立的规范模式、实质内容以及适用方式.
The Independent Evidence and Institutional Realization of Supervisory Obligations of Chinese Companies——The Improvement of the Obligations of Supervisors in the Draft Revised Company Law
The arrangement of supervisory obligations of companies in mainland China has always been characterized by non-independence.Not only does the company legislation insist on the homogeneous assumption of supervisory obligations and directors'obligations for a long time,but the provisions of supervisory obligations also present the phenomenon of enabling attachment in judicial practice.The consistent confusion between the obligations of supervisors and directors objectively ignores the differences between the roles of supervisors and directors,blurs the doctrinal field of application of fiduciary duties,and to a certain extent creates a practical dilemma of the weakness of the supervisory system.In essence,the supervisors of companies in mainland China are not qualified trustees of the fiduciary duties of the company law,and they do not meet the specific conditions to enjoy the"distinction"of fiduciary duties.The independence of the obligations of the company supervisors can fully utilize the mandatory nature of the obligations and the specific guidelines of the content of the acts to activate the supervisory system's supervisory efficacy,and the stability and predictability of the obligations of the supervisors also make it possible for the obligations of the company supervisors to be independent.Therefore,in order to contribute to the effective realization of the operation of the corporate supervisory system,it is appropriate to adopt an independent regulatory model,independent substance and independent application for the future amendment of the obligations of corporate supervisors.

赵万一、苏志猛

展开 >

西南政法大学民商法学院 重庆,401120

公司法 监事义务 独立 信义义务

2024

学术研究
广东省社会科学界联合会

学术研究

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:0.702
ISSN:1000-7326
年,卷(期):2024.(3)
  • 47