首页|《贵州苗民》与林耀华早期民族研究的思想和方法考察

《贵州苗民》与林耀华早期民族研究的思想和方法考察

扫码查看
林耀华的博士论文《贵州苗民》是其由汉人家族研究转向少数民族研究的首篇作品。1940年文章写成之时,国家正面临分裂危机,该文凝聚了林耀华的学术洞见和家国情感。林耀华借助历史文献、人类学理论、民族志材料为《黔南职方纪略》所述苗民历史与社会特点作注。20世纪三四十年代学者们围绕体质、语言与文化因素进行西南民族分类,林耀华通过历史研究发现,西南地区历史上的政治集团为族群边界提供框架,西南族群天然具有政治内涵,体质、语言与文化只是族群边界的表达形式。现代国家建设需要实现边疆的政治体制和经济方式变革,《贵州苗民》通过社会习俗研究发现,边疆地区存在平等主义和等级主义两种社会状态,现代国家要求实现等级主义向平等主义的转变,这促成了林耀华的彝族和藏族政治制度研究。《贵州苗民》发现苗民存在不善积累财富、慷慨消耗财物的经济心态,这与林耀华关于彝汉经济和彝族现代化的思考一脉相承。林耀华运用史料、民族志材料形成的苗民社会判断和实地调查的功能主义分析相结合,也是中国民族学"南派"和"北派"研究取向相结合的典范。
"The Miao-Man Peoples of Kweichow"and Lin Yueh-hwa's Thoughts and Methods in His Early Ethnic Studies
LinYueh-hwa's doctoral dissertation"The Miao-Man Peoples of Kweichow"is the first work of his research on Han turning to the study of ethnic minorities.The article was completed in 1940 when the country was being devided.This article embodies Lin's academic insights and patriotism.Lin used historical documents,anthropological theories and ethnographic materials to annotate the historical and social characteristics of the Miao-Man people described in"Ch'ien-nan Chih-fang Chi-lüeh".From 1930s to 1940s,scholars tried to classify nationalities from the perspective of physique,language and culture.Through historical research,Lin found that the political groups in the history of Southwest China provided a framework for ethnic boundaries,and the southwest ethnic groups were naturally political,while physique and culture were only expressions of ethnic boundaries.Modem country needs to realize the change of political system and economic mode in the border areas."The Miao-Man Peoples of Kweichow"found there was hierarchy and equality in the border areas through the study of social customs,and modem country demands the transformation from hierarchy to equality,which promoted the study of political system of Yi and Tibetan."The Miao-Man Peoples of Kweichow"found that the Miao-Man people had an economic habit of poor accumulation and generous consumption,which is related to Lin's thougts on economic modernization of Yi.Lin's judgement from the Miao-Man people's history,which was combined with his fieldwork.It was also a case of the combination of"South Branch"and"North Branch"in China Ethnology.

Lin Yueh-hwa"The Miao-Man Peoples of Kweichow"multinational countrymethodology

罗仕韶、黄剑波

展开 >

华东师范大学社会发展学院(上海200241)

林耀华 《贵州苗民》 民族国家 方法论

国家社会科学基金重点项目(2023)

23AMZ005

2024

学术月刊
上海市社会科学界联合会

学术月刊

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:0.846
ISSN:0439-8041
年,卷(期):2024.56(5)
  • 44