首页|"权力秩序"与清末政体变革:基于新框架的分析

"权力秩序"与清末政体变革:基于新框架的分析

扫码查看
从政治学的根本关怀出发,政体变革本质上是权力关系—结构变动的过程和结果。以"权力秩序"为核心概念的分析框架,旨在借鉴迈克尔·曼的社会权力类型学,结合过程追踪方法理念,构建起"权力主体与主体性权力关系"的结构性分析单元,以及"权力结构形态的解体与形塑"的两大过程性分析维度,进而重探清末政体变革。分析发现,清末存在政治权力悬置、军事权力转移、意识形态权力重构、经济权力萎靡的情形,君主制所依赖的"政治权力—意识形态权力""政治权力—军事权力"强结构相继解体,进而导致政治失序。在时代心态与西方意识形态力量的形塑下,彼时的知识分子急切擘画着中国现代政制的未来,然而他们所欲构建的理想政体消耗在了复杂的权力秩序变动之中。革命党与立宪派虽以短暂的合作完成了辛亥革命,但革命后所建立的共和制终究有名无实,与"理想型"共和政制的设置原则并不相符,最终以军人干政的局面收场。
"Power Order"and the Reform of Regime in the Late Qing Dynasty:An Analysis Based on a New Framework
From the fundamental concern of political science,reform of regime is essentially the process and result of changes in power relations and structures.The analytical framework with"power order"as the core concept aims to draw on Michael Mann's social power typology and combine the concept of process tracing methods to construct a structural unit analyzing"the relations between subject of power and the subjective power",and two process dimensions analyzing"disintegration and shaping of power structure form",and then to revisit the political reform in the late Qing Dynasty.The analysis finds there appeared such situations as political power suspension,military power transition,ideological power reconstruction,and economic power sluggishness in the late Qing Dynasty,which means the strong structure of"political power-ideological power"and"political power-military power"that the monarchy relied on was disintegrated,resulting in political disorder.Shaped by the mentality of the epoch and the West ideology,the Chinese intellectuals of that time were eager to chart the future of China's modem political system,but the ideal government they wanted to establish dissipated in complex changes of the"power order".Although the revolutionaries and the constitutionalists cooperated and launched the"1911 Revolution",the republic established after the revolution was merely nominal after all,which did not conform to the principles of establising the"ideal"republic,and finally ended in the domestic military intervention.

the late Qing Dynasty and the early Republic of Chinaregimereform of regimepower orderpower structure

袁超、董振光

展开 >

深圳大学政府管理学院(广东深圳518055)

清末民初 政体 政体变革 权力秩序 权力结构

2024

学术月刊
上海市社会科学界联合会

学术月刊

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:0.846
ISSN:0439-8041
年,卷(期):2024.56(12)