首页|行政协议范围的法教义学分析

行政协议范围的法教义学分析

扫码查看
行政协议作为行政机关实施职能的一种独特方式,在一定程度上会限制或剥夺公民的基本权利,因此其内容必须要符合合宪性审查,以保障私权与公权之间的平衡。《关于审理行政协议案件的司法解释》不仅规定了行政协议的概念还创设了"兜底条款",这就造成了行政协议范围的开放性和不确定性,不符合法律保留原则,亦对实在法的稳定预期造成影响,在实践中还会为腐败滋生预留空间。因此,需要通过对行政协议的概念和本质内涵进行法教义学的意义阐释,提炼出符合合宪性审查和比例原则的认定标准,按照功能主义的进路和同类解释的进路,明确划定行政协议的范围。
Legal Dogmatic Analysis of the Scope of Administrative Agreement
As a unique way of implementing the functions of the executive branch,administrative agreements to a certain extent limit or deprive citizens of their basic rights,so their contents must be in line with the constitutional review,to ensure the balance be-tween private and public rights.The"Judicial Interpretation on the Hearing of Administrative Agreement Cases"not only stipulates the concept of the administrative agreement but also creates"bottom line provisions",which leads to the openness and uncertainty of the scope of the administrative agreement,not in line with the principle of legal reservation,affects the expectation of stability of positive law,and in practice leaves room for the breeding of corruption.Therefore,it is necessary to refine the criteria for the recognition of ad-ministrative agreements in accordance with the principles of constitutional review and proportionality by means of a doctrinal interpreta-tion of the concept and essence of administrative agreements.According to the approach of functionalism and the approach of similar in-terpretation,the scope of administrative agreement should be clearly defined.

administrative agreementdogmatics of lawfunctional differentiationthe principle of proportionalityconstitutional review

王冠艺

展开 >

内蒙古检察官进修学院,内蒙古呼和浩特 010000

行政协议 法教义学 功能分化 比例原则 合宪性审查

内蒙古自治区人民检察院重点调研课题

NJ202334

2024

阴山学刊
包头师范学院

阴山学刊

CHSSCD
影响因子:0.127
ISSN:1004-1869
年,卷(期):2024.37(4)
  • 16