首页|英国代孕规制:历史进展和未解决的问题

英国代孕规制:历史进展和未解决的问题

扫码查看
英国法律委员会在 2023年的报告中提出了代孕规制的"新途径",对于代孕协议能否强制执行的问题进行了详尽的讨论,并总结出两种可行建议,即代孕协议"规范但不可执行"说或"部分可强制执行"说.但该报告仍未就是否允许商业代孕提出确定建议,需要进一步探讨.基于英国经验,可考虑制定专门的法律法规规制代孕,规定监督机构与管理流程.借鉴代孕有限性合法化模式,排除商业代孕和非生理障碍性代孕.在亲子认定关系问题上,参考英国的"父母令"程序分情况讨论,基因代孕遵循分娩者为母原则,妊娠代孕考虑推定预期父母为合法父母原则.
UK Surrogacy Regulation:Historical Progress and Unresolved Issues
The UK Law Commission's 2023 report proposed a"new approach"to regulate surrogacy in the UK.Whether surrogacy agreements can be legally enforced has been discussed at length and two feasible recommendations have been summarized,namely,either surrogacy agreements should be"regulated but unenforceable"or"partially enforceable".However,the report did not provide a definitive recommendation on whether commercial surrogacy should be allowed,and this needs to be explored further.Based on the experience of the UK,China may consider enacting specific laws and regulations to regulate surrogacy,including the establishment of supervisory body and management process.A limited legalization model for surrogacy should be implemented,excluding commercial surrogacy and surrogacy for non-physical disabilities.On the issue of parentage determination,reference is made in the"Parental Order"procedure in the UK,with genetic surrogacy following the"birth mother is the legal mother"principle,while gestational surrogacy could presume the intended parents as the legal parents.

UK surrogacysurrogacy agreementcommercial surrogacylegalization of surrogacy

马一迪、刘文楷

展开 >

东南大学法学院 江苏南京 211100

新加坡国立大学法学院 新加坡新加坡 259776

英国代孕 代孕协议 商业代孕 代孕合法化

2024年江苏省研究生科研创新计划项目

KYCX24_0340

2024

医学与哲学
中国自然辩证法研究会

医学与哲学

CSTPCDCHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:1.314
ISSN:1002-0772
年,卷(期):2024.45(17)
  • 1