首页|庭审实质化视角下讯问被告人程序改革研究

庭审实质化视角下讯问被告人程序改革研究

Research on the Reform of the Defendant Interrogation Procedure from the Perspective of Substantial Court Hearings

扫码查看
"以审判为中心"的刑事诉讼制度改革,重心在于庭审实质化的实现.然而,我国刑事法庭调查阶段讯问被告人程序存在诸多问题,成为了庭审实质化的明显阻碍.该程序在我国刑事诉讼中发挥着对庭审走向定调、确定被告人认罪态度及案件争点和与控方优势暗合的实际作用.比较研究表明,刑事诉讼程序包括讯问被告人程序的设计应始终遵循"不得强迫任何人证明自己有罪"的基本理念.我国的讯问被告人程序,是"职权主义诉讼模式""印证证明模式"和"案卷笔录中心主义"共同形塑下的产物.在未来的《刑事诉讼法》修改中,应当对该程序进行改革,赋予被告人选择是否作为控方证人接受检察官询问的权利,凸显被告人的主体性地位,优化调整庭审布局,以推进庭审实质化的落实,进而确保司法公正的实现.
The reform of the criminal procedure system"centered on trial"focuses on the realization of substantial court hearings.However,there are numerous issues in the interrogation of defendants during the criminal court investigation stage in China,which has become a significant obstacle to the substantialization of court hearings.This procedure plays an actual role in setting the tone for the trial,determining the defendant's attitude toward guilt,identifying the disputed points of the case,and aligning with the prosecution's advantages.Comparative studies show that the design of criminal procedures,including the defendant interrogation procedure,should always adhere to the fundamental principle of"no one shall be compelled to prove their own guilt."The interrogation procedure in China's criminal procedure is the result of a combination of the"inquisitorial trial model,"the"corroborative evidence model,"and the"record-centric approach."In future amendments to the"Criminal Procedure Law,"this procedure should be reformed to grant defendants the right to choose whether to accept interrogation by the prosecutor as a prosecution witness.This would highlight the defendant's subjective status,optimize the layout of court hearings,and promote the realization of substantial court hearings,thereby ensuring the achievement of judicial fairness.

trial-centeredsubstantial court hearingsinterrogation of defendantsequality of prosecution and defense

李奋飞

展开 >

中国人民大学法学院、纪检监察学院,北京 100872

以审判为中心 庭审实质化 讯问被告人 控辩平等

2024

政法论丛
山东政法学院

政法论丛

CSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:0.943
ISSN:1002-6274
年,卷(期):2024.(5)