首页|行政协议之诉赔偿与补偿情形认定

行政协议之诉赔偿与补偿情形认定

Administrative Agreement Litigation Indemnity and Compensation Situation Recognition

扫码查看
行政协议之诉赔偿、补偿有其自身的特殊性,既有别于行政赔偿、行政补偿,也不属于民事赔偿、民事补偿,当前理论界有争议,实务中法官可以依法作出不同的裁判.判断行政机关在行政协议之诉中承担赔偿责任还是补偿责任,原则上应为合法优先、兼顾公益,合法行为造成的损失予以补偿,违法行为造成的损失予以赔偿,但为了公共利益需要且仅是程序违法的情况下,可以只给予补偿.行政协议之诉赔偿、补偿应尽可能明确具体标准,不能明确的,应比照行政赔偿适当增加,而且赔偿应高于补偿.对行政协议纠纷作出裁判应优先适用行政法律规范,即便需要参照适用民事法律规范,也需要考量能否有效维护社会公共利益,不能随意参照适用.
Administrative agreement litigation indemnity and compensation have their own particularity,which is different from administrative indemnity and administrative compensation,and does not belong to civil indemnity and civil compensation.There is currently controversy in the theoretical field,and in practice,judges can make different judgments in accordance with the law.To determine whether an administrative agency should bear indemnity liability or compensation liability in an administrative agreement lawsuit,the principle should prioritize legality and take into account public welfare.Compensation shall be given for losses caused by legal action,and indemnity shall be given for losses caused by illegal action.However,in the case of public interest needs and only procedural violations,compensation can be given only.The indemnity and compensation for administrative agreements should be as clear as possible with specific standards.If they cannot be clearly defined,they should be appropriately increased in comparison to administrative indemnity,and indemnity should be higher than compensation.When making judgments on administrative agreement disputes,priority should be given to the application of administrative legal norms.Even if it is necessary to refer to the application of civil legal norms,it is also necessary to consider whether it can effectively safeguard social public interests.It cannot be arbitrarily referred to or applied.

administrative agreementindemnity and compensationlegal precedencegive consideration to public welfarereference application

张敏

展开 >

山东政法学院法学院,山东济南 250014

行政协议 赔偿补偿 合法优先 兼顾公益 参照适用

2024

政法论丛
山东政法学院

政法论丛

CSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:0.943
ISSN:1002-6274
年,卷(期):2024.(5)