首页|居住权效力的体系化冲突与协调

居住权效力的体系化冲突与协调

Systematized Conflict and Coordination of the Validity of the Right of Habitation

扫码查看
作为《民法典》新增物权制度,居住权有增加所有权人的债权人负担之虞,引发法典内权利冲突问题.保障功能定位与适用边界模糊造成居住权权利冲突的法律适用困境.物权优于债权、成立在先权利优先、法定权利优于意定权利等法律解释观点亦难满足复杂的居住利益平衡要求.居住权与租赁合同、亲属关系、公序良俗原则共同构成了居住利益保护体系,并有各自调整的法益对象.厘清我国经济社会发展和制度规范体系对新增居住权的实证需求可明确这一制度的立法意旨与适用对象.居住权权利冲突下的法律适用,应以识别"真正"居住权为前提,以居住权合同约定的法益实现位阶为依据;在无约定的情形下,应平等保护居住利益与债权的实现.
As a new property right added to the Civil Code,right of habitation may increase the burden on the owner's creditors and give rise to the problem of conflicting rights within the Code.The ambiguity between the positioning of the function of protection and the boundary of application creates a dilemma in the legal application of the conflict of rights in the right of habitation.It is also difficult to meet the requirements of balancing the residency interests,such as the legal interpretation that property rights are superior to claims,the priority of rights established first,and the superiority of legal rights over intentional rights.The right of habitation,together with the lease contract,kinship,and the principle of public order and good morals,constitute the protection system of residency interests,and have their own adjustment objects of legal interests.Clarification of the empirical needs about local economic and social development and institutional system for the new right can clarify the legislative intent of right of habitation.The application of the law in the event of a conflict of rights in the right of habitation should be based on the premise of identifying the"real"right of habitation,and on the order of realization of the legal interests agreed upon in the contract on a right of habitation.In the absence of such an agreement,the equal protection should be given to the residency interests and the realization of creditor's rights.

right of habitationresidency interestsconflict of rightsa legal system with Chinese characteristics

姚宇

展开 >

辽宁大学法学院,辽宁沈阳 110036

居住权 居住利益 权利冲突 中国特色法学体系

2024

政法论丛
山东政法学院

政法论丛

CSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:0.943
ISSN:1002-6274
年,卷(期):2024.(6)