首页|行政犯"行刑衔接"困境破解:从分离式到联动式

行政犯"行刑衔接"困境破解:从分离式到联动式

扫码查看
20世纪90年代,有案不移、有案难移、以罚代刑是我国法治建设的难题,为此建立了刑事优先论,要求案件涉嫌犯罪事实时及时移送侦查机关,中止行政违法调查.基于行政前置性要求以及刑法谦抑性考量,实践中采取行政优先论,多数行政犯案件由行政执法部门以执法程序主导调查,在基本查清犯罪事实后再移送公安机关.由于行政机关调查能力不足,影响案件事实真相的查明.刑事优先论与行政优先论都是建立在违法调查与犯罪侦查相分离的基础上,成为制约"行刑衔接"的主要问题.对"行政犯"的违法犯罪调查,需要发挥行政机关和侦查机关的共同作用,"行刑衔接"应当从分离式走向联动式,赋予公安机关在案件涉嫌犯罪时及时介入调查的职权,在调查过程中行政机关与公安机关充分配合,协同调查违法犯罪事实.
In the 1990s,the problems in the construction of the rule of law in China,such as not transferring cases,difficulty in transferring cases,and substituting penalties for punishment,led to the establishment of the doctrine of criminal priority,which requires that cases suspected of having committed crimes be transferred to the investigating authorities in a timely manner,and that investigations of administrative offenses be discontinued.Based on the administrative prepositive requirement and the modesty of criminal law,administrative priority has been adopted in practice,with most cases of administrative offenses being investigated by administrative law-enforcing departments in accordance with law enforcement procedures,and then transferred to the public security organs after the facts of the crime are basically ascertained.The lack of investigative capacity of administrative authorities affects the ascertainment of the facts of the case.Both the criminal priority theory and the administrative priority theory are based on the separation of the investigation of violations of the law and the investigation of crimes,which is not conducive to the clarification of the convergence of administrative law and criminal law.The investigation of'administrative offenders'needs a joint role of administrative authorities and investigating authorities,and the convergence of the two laws of national governance should be changed from a separate type to a linkage type,to give public security organs the authority to intervene in the investigation of offenses in a timely manner when they are suspected of committing a crime,so as to ensure that in the process of investigation,the administrative authorities and public security organs can fully cooperate with each other to investigate the facts of illegal and criminal offenses in a coordinated manner.

谢小剑

展开 >

江西财经大学法学院

行刑衔接 行政执法 刑事侦查 联勤联动

江西省"双千计划"哲学社会科学领军人才项目(2023)

jxsq2023203008

2024

中国法学
中国法学会

中国法学

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:6.241
ISSN:1003-1707
年,卷(期):2024.(2)
  • 61