首页|论数据信息损害的承认与救济

论数据信息损害的承认与救济

扫码查看
无损害则无赔偿,承认损害是民事救济的前提.个人信息和数据非法处理等行为可能引致非物质性数据信息损害,但其却因与传统损害要素不兼容而难获法律承认.本着风险分配与公共治理的观念,发挥侵权制度的个体救济与风险预防功能,承认数据信息损害的独立性具有制度必要性和学理可行性.回溯从工业时代到数字时代的社会生产方式变革可以发现,传统损害概念实质是基于社会生产方式而建构的.这为承认数据信息损害提供了充分的法理依据,可解决不确定性、因果关系和个体显著性的制度障碍.数据信息损害救济的实现一方面需要将已经发生的个人信息数据被非法收集、访问、泄露与丢失等直接数据信息损害法定化,并对后续数据信息损害进行类型化扩容,承认典型常见的非物质损害类型;另一方面,对微小系统性的数据信息类损害应采用公益诉讼的方式进行救济,并以法定赔偿方式加以衡量.
The principle of'no harm,no compensation'means that the recognition of harm is a prerequisite for civil remedies.Actions such as the illegal processing of personal information and data may cause non-material data and information harm.However,this form of harm is difficult to gain legal recognition due to its incompatibility with traditional elements of harm.With the concepts of risk distribution and public governance in mind,it is institutionally necessary and theoretically feasible to acknowledge the independence of data and information harm,leveraging the tort system's functions of individual relief and risk prevention.Firstly,there should be a shift in mindset to understand that the traditional concept of harm is constructed based on the social mode of production.The transformation from the industrial age to the digital age provides ample legal basis for recognizing data and information harm,addressing institutional barriers related to uncertainty,causality,and individual significance.Secondly,remedial rules should be adjusted.On one hand,direct data and information harm,such as illegal collection,access,leakage,and loss of personal information data,should be legalized,and subsequent data and information harm should be expanded in a typified manner,acknowledging common types of non-material harm.On the other hand,for minor systemic data and information harm,public interest litigation should be used as a remedial measure,with statutory compensation methods employed for quantification.

张凌寒

展开 >

中国政法大学数据法治研究院

数据信息损害 个人信息 损害法定化 公益诉讼 法定赔偿

国家社会科学基金重点项目(2023)

23AFX009

2024

中国法学
中国法学会

中国法学

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:6.241
ISSN:1003-1707
年,卷(期):2024.(3)
  • 12