首页|"超期申请行政复议"的形成逻辑与体系化应对

"超期申请行政复议"的形成逻辑与体系化应对

扫码查看
"超期申请行政复议"是在行政复议申请期限和行政诉讼起诉期限均已届满的情况下,当事人寻求行政救济的实用理性策略,其以"申请行政复议→收到不予受理或者驳回行政复议决定→提起行政诉讼"为基本结构.这种实用理性表现为仰赖行政诉讼解决纠纷的公正性和实效性,以先复议后诉讼的方式,规避原行政行为的起诉期限.既有司法实践基于解释论的"裁定不予立案"与"判决驳回诉讼请求"方案均存在对程序问题的不当处理并伴随衍生风险."超期申请行政复议"亟需立法论的体系化回应.一方面,通过行政诉讼程序的三阶段改良和权利保护必要性审查机制的构建,在诉讼内部以"裁定驳回起诉"优化一般性应对方案;另一方面,通过设置合理有效的行政程序重开制度和行政违法行为检察监督制度,于诉讼外部补阙例外性的应对方案,在确保普遍正义与个案正义相统一的基础上推进相关争议的实质性解决.
'Overdue application for administrative reconsideration',whose basic structure is'applying for an administrative reconsideration → receiving a decision not to accept or to reject an administrative reconsideration → filing an administrative lawsuit',acts as a concrete strategy for the party to seek practical rationality in administrative relief when the time limit for administrative reconsideration application and administrative litigation has both expired.To be specific,this practical rationality is manifested in two aspects.For one thing,it depends on the fairness and effectiveness of administrative litigation in solving disputes.For another thing,it is to evade the statutory time limit for prosecution of the original administrative acts by means of administrative reconsideration and then litigation.In judicial practice,the two schemes of'a ruling not to file the case'and'a judgment to dismiss the plaintiff's claims'are not the optimal solutions for dealing with'overdue application for administrative reconsideration'.Therefore,considering the deficiencies in the existing interpretative schemes,there is an urgent need for systematic countermeasures for'overdue application for administrative reconsideration'from the perspective of legislation.Specifically,within litigation,the general response can be optimized for'a ruling to dismiss the lawsuit'through the three-stage improvement of administrative litigation procedure and the construction of the review mechanism in the necessity of rights protection.Outside of litigation,the exceptional response can be supplemented by establishing reasonable and effective systems for reopening administrative procedures and for prosecuting and supervising illegal administrative acts.From this,the substantive settlement of relevant disputes can be promoted on the basis of ensuring the unity of universal justice and case-by-case justice.

范伟

展开 >

中国政法大学法律硕士学院

超期申请行政复议 起诉期限 诉的利益 行政争议实质性解决

2024

中国法学
中国法学会

中国法学

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:6.241
ISSN:1003-1707
年,卷(期):2024.(6)