首页|国家公园为主体的自然保护地采矿权退出补偿方式研究

国家公园为主体的自然保护地采矿权退出补偿方式研究

扫码查看
在国家公园为主体的自然保护地建设中,妥善处理采矿权退出补偿方式是平衡生态保护与矿产资源开发的关键。研究深入剖析自然保护地内采矿权退出补偿方式的立法与司法实践,揭示了其存在的复杂性特征。这种复杂性归因于三方面,一是补偿范围模糊笼统,直接损失范围不统一,间接损失常被忽略;二是补偿标准设定粗略,未体现分类管理原则,缺乏科学评估方法,且补偿结果的可接受性低,影响了补偿标准的合理性、科学性和公正性;三是补偿手段平面单一,资金补偿受限于财政压力与评估难题,而非资金补偿方式面临操作复杂和难以落地执行。鉴于此,有必要完善目前的补偿方式,具体而言:在补偿范围上,应公平合理地认定直接损失,基于权益限制的区别划分具体赔偿内容,且扣除公平负担,同时全面考虑间接损失。在补偿标准上,应根据自然保护地的类型和功能分区制定三类补偿标准,并采用贴现现金流量法与可比销售法等科学方法来确定补偿金额,同时确保补偿的公正性。在补偿手段上,应优化资金补偿的筹措机制,并强化非现金补偿方式的制度化衔接。最终,在国家公园的自然保护地体系建设中形成采矿权退出补偿方式的制度合力,以最严密的法治思维促进国家公园为主体自然保护地建设的高质量发展。
Study on the compensation mode of mining right withdrawal in nature reserves with national parks as the main body
In the construction of national parks as the mainstay of nature reserves,the proper handling of compensation for the withdrawal of mining rights is the key to balancing ecological protection and the development of mineral resources.The study deeply analyzes the legislation and judicial practice of compensation for withdrawal of mining rights in nature reserves,and reveals the complexity of its characteristics.This complexity is attributed to three aspects:first,the scope of compensation is vague and general,the scope of direct loss is not uniform,and indirect loss is often ignored;second,the compensation standard is set roughly,does not reflect the principle of classification management,lacks the scientific assessment method,and the acceptability of the compensation result is low,which affects the reasonableness,scientificity,and fairness of the compensation standard;third,the means of compensation is flat and single,and the financial compensation is limited by the financial pressure and assessment problems,while the non-financial compensation method faces the same difficulties as the financial compensation method.difficulties,while the non-funded compensation methods face operational complexity and difficulty in implementation on the ground.In view of this,it is necessary to improve the current compensation methods,specifically:in terms of the scope of compensation,direct losses should be recognized fairly and reasonably,and specific compensation should be divided based on the distinction of limitation of rights and interests,with deduction of the fair burden,and indirect losses should be considered in a comprehensive manner.In terms of compensation standards,three types of compensation standards should be formulated according to the types and functional zoning of nature reserves,and scientific methods such as the discounted cash flow method and the comparable sales method should be used to determine the amount of compensation and ensure the fairness of compensation.In terms of compensation means,the financing mechanism of capital compensation should be optimized,and the institutionalization of non-cash compensation methods should be strengthened.Ultimately,the systematic synergy of compensation for mining right withdrawal should be formed in the construction of nature reserve system of national parks,so as to promote the high-quality development of the construction of nature reserve with national parks as the main body of nature reserve with the most rigorous thinking of the rule of law.

mineral resource managementmining rightnational parknature reserve systemcompensation modalities for withdrawal of mining right

袁智雨、王娟、刘鑫、郭琳琳

展开 >

内蒙古大学法学院,内蒙古 呼和浩特 010070

内蒙古自然资源法治研究中心,内蒙古 呼和浩特 010070

浙江省杭州市临平区人民政府乔司街道办事处,浙江 杭州 311323

自然资源部咨询研究中心,北京 100035

展开 >

矿产资源管理 采矿权 国家公园 自然保护地体系 采矿权退出补偿方式

司法部项目内蒙古自治区高等学校人文社会科学重点研究项目

22SFB5045NJSZ23033

2024

中国矿业
中国矿业联合会

中国矿业

CSTPCD北大核心
影响因子:0.875
ISSN:1004-4051
年,卷(期):2024.33(z2)