首页|药学服务对重症监护病房患者治疗效果及经济学价值的系统评价

药学服务对重症监护病房患者治疗效果及经济学价值的系统评价

扫码查看
目的 评价药学服务对于重症监护病房患者的治疗效果及经济学价值,为后续研究提供方法学的参考.方法 检索中国知网、万方、维普、PubMed、Embase和Cochrane Library数据库,检索时间从建库起至2022年 11月,纳入针对重症监护病房患者的药学服务效果及经济学评价的所有原始研究,对其研究方法、治疗相关指标和经济学指标进行系统评价.结果 最终纳入研究20项,样本量 100~500例的有10项(50.00%),研究周期小于12个月的有14项(70.00%).病例对照研究2项,队列研究9项,另有9项研究未设立对照组.最常用的治疗相关指标为不良反应发生率(n=3,15.00%)和药物相关问题(n=3,15.00%),所有研究结果均显示药学服务对重症监护病房患者的治疗效果有改善作用.药品费用(n=9,45.00%)是最常用的经济学指标,研究结果显示药学服务会减少药品治疗费用及住院费用等,但可能会增加药师劳动力成本.6项研究进行了成本-效益分析,结果显示重症监护病房患者药学服务的成本-效益比为1.55∶1~25∶1,卫生经济学评价质量评分为62.00±8.41.结论 药学服务可改善重症监护病房患者治疗效果,并节约治疗成本,具有一定的成本-效益,但相关研究的质量有待进一步提高.
Pharmaceutical services on treatment outcomes and economic value in intensive care unit patients:a systematic review
AIM To evaluate the treatment outcomes and economic value of pharmaceutical services for intensive care unit(ICU)patients,and to provide a methodological reference for subsequent research.METHODS Data from CNKI,Wanfang,VIP,PubMed,Embase,and Cochrane Library databases were retrieved from inception to November 2022.All original studies examining the effectiveness and economic evaluation of pharmaceutical services for ICU patients were included.A systematic review of their research methods,health outcome indicators,and economic indicators was conducted.RESULTS A total of 20 articles were ultimately included,with a sample size of 100 to 500 cases in 10 studies(50.00%)and a study period of less than 12 months in 14 studies(70.00%).There were 2 case-control studies,9 cohort studies,and 9 studies without a control group.The common treatment-related indicators were the incidence of adverse reactions(n=3,15.00%)and drug-related problems(n=3,15.00%).All studies consistently demonstrated the beneficial effects of pharmaceutical services on treatment outcomes.The most frequently used economic indicator was medication costs(n=9,45.00%).The results showed that pharmaceutical services can reduce medication treatment costs and hospitalization expenses,but may increase pharmacist labor costs.6 studies conducted cost-benefit analyses,revealing that the cost-benefit ratio of pharmaceutical services for ICU patients ranged from 1.55∶1 to 25∶1.The quality score of health economics evaluations was 62.00±8.41.CONCLUSIONS Pharmaceutical services can enhance the therapeutic effectiveness and reduce the cost of treatment for ICU patients,demonstrating a positive cost-benefit ratio.However,the quality of subsequent studies needs to be further improved.

intensive care unit patientpharmaceutical serviceeconomic evaluationsystematic review

魏春燕、严知静、何金汗、武志昂、胡明

展开 >

四川大学华西药学院,成都 610041

四川大学华西医院临床药学部,成都 610041

沈阳药科大学亦弘商学院,北京 100055

重症监护病房患者 药学服务 经济学评价 系统评价

2024

中国临床药学杂志
中国药学会

中国临床药学杂志

CSTPCD
影响因子:0.502
ISSN:1007-4406
年,卷(期):2024.33(1)
  • 18