首页|几种钝化材料对铅冶炼场地土壤重金属的钝化修复效果

几种钝化材料对铅冶炼场地土壤重金属的钝化修复效果

扫码查看
通过土壤培养试验,评估了水泥、锰磷改性生物炭和锰磷改性谷壳灰在0%、1%、2%、4%4个施用量下对铅冶炼场地土壤pH以及Cd、Pb和微量元素(Zn、Fe和Mn)有效态含量的影响.研究结果显示:随着水泥施用量的提高,铅冶炼场地土壤pH显著提高,Cd和Pb有效性逐渐降低,水泥处理济源某冶炼场地和株洲某冶炼场地土壤pH分别提高0.89~1.84和0.89~1.76个单位,DTPA-Cd含量分别降低34.3%~53.1%(P<0.05)和59.6%~73.2%(P<0.05),DTPA-Pb含量分别降低21.6%~44.7%(P<0.05)和38.4%~44.3%(P<0.05).随着锰磷改性生物炭和锰磷改性谷壳灰施用量的提高,铅冶炼场地土壤pH与Cd和Pb有效性均逐渐降低.4%锰磷改性生物炭处理两铅冶炼场地土壤pH分别降低0.51(济源)和0.40(株洲)个单位,DTPA-Cd含量显著降低18.0%(济源)和39.8%(株洲),DTPA-Pb含量显著降低37.8%(济源)和63.1%(株洲).4%锰磷改性谷壳灰处理两铅冶炼场地土壤pH分别降低0.70(济源)和0.23(株洲)个单位,DTPA-Cd含量显著降低14.9%(济源)和30.2%(株洲),DTPA-Pb含量显著降低37.3%(济源)和54.1%(株洲).4%水泥处理两铅冶炼场地土壤DTPA-Zn含量分别显著降低36.5%(济源)和59.4%(株洲),DTPA-Fe含量分别显著提高122.7%(济源)和142.9%(株洲),DTPA-Mn含量分别显著降低13.8%(济源)和69.1%(株洲).4%锰磷改性生物炭处理土壤DTPA-Zn含量显著提高48.7%(济源),DTPA-Mn含量分别显著提高409.7%(济源)和538.6%(株洲),DTPA-Fe含量分别显著降低33.4%(济源)和30.7%(株洲).4%锰磷改性谷壳灰处理土壤DTPA-Zn含量显著提高63.0%(济源),DTPA-Mn含量分别显著提高290.3%(济源)和73.5%(株洲),DTPA-Fe含量分别显著降低9.5%(济源)和12.0%(株洲).3种钝化材料降低两铅冶炼场地Cd有效性顺序均为水泥>锰磷改性生物炭>锰磷改性谷壳灰,降低Pb有效性顺序分别为水泥>锰磷改性生物炭>锰磷改性谷壳灰(济源)和锰磷改性生物炭>锰磷改性谷壳灰>水泥(株洲).研究建议根据铅冶炼场地的具体Cd和Pb污染特征选择合适的钝化材料,以实现对土壤Cd和Pb的有效同步钝化.
Immobilization Remediation Effect of Several Passivation Materials on Heavy Metals in Soil of Lead Smelting Sites
A soil incubation experiment was conducted to study the effects of cement,Mn-P modified biochar and Mn-P modified rice husk ash on soil pH and the available concentration of Cd,Pb and trace elements(Zn,Fe and Mn)in lead smelting site soils under four application rates of 0%,1%,2%and 4%.The results showed that with the increase of cement application rate,the pH of the lead smelting site soils significantly increased,and the availability of Cd and Pb decreased gradually.The soil pH of a smelting site in Jiyuan and a smelting site in Zhuzhou treated with cement increased by 0.89-1.84 and 0.89-1.76 units,respectively.The DTPA-Cd concentration treated with cement decreased by 34.3%-53.1%(P<0.05)and 59.6%-73.2%(P<0.05),and DTPA-Pb concentration decreased by 21.6%-44.7%(P<0.05)and 38.4%-44.3%(P<0.05),respectively.With the increase of application rates of Mn-P modified biochar and Mn-P modified rice husk ash,the soil pH,and Cd and Pb availability in lead smelting sites gradually decreased.The treatment of 4%Mn-P modified biochar reduced the soil pH of two lead smelting sites by 0.51(Jiyuan)and 0.40(Zhuzhou)units,respectively.The DTPA-Cd concentration significantly decreased by 18.0%(Jiyuan)and 39.8%(Zhuzhou),and DTPA-Pb concentration significantly decreased by 37.8%(Jiyuan)and 63.1%(Zhuzhou).The soil pH value of the two lead smelting sites treated with 4%Mn-P modified rice husk ash decreased by 0.70(Jiyuan)and 0.23(Zhuzhou)units,respectively.The DTP A-Cd concentration significantly decreased by 14.9%(Jiyuan)and 30.2%(Zhuzhou),and the DTPA-Pb concentration significantly decreased by 37.3%(Jiyuan)and 54.1%(Zhuzhou).The DTPA-Zn concentration in the soil of two lead smelting sites treated with 4%cement significantly decreased by 36.5%(Jiyuan)and 59.4%(Zhuzhou),respectively,and the DTPA-Fe concentration significantly increased by 122.7%(Jiyuan)and 142.9%(Zhuzhou),and the DTPA-Mn concentration significantly decreased by 13.8%(Jiyuan)and 69.1%(Zhuzhou),respectively.The treatment of 4%Mn-P modified biochar significantly increased the soil DTPA-Zn concentration by 48.7%(Jiyuan),and the DTPA-Mn concentration significantly increased by 409.7%(Jiyuan)and 538.6%(Zhuzhou),and the DTPA-Fe concentration significantly decreased by 33.4%(Jiyuan)and 30.7%(Zhuzhou),respectively.The treatment of 4%Mn-P modified rice husk ash significantly increased the soil DTPA-Zn concentration by 63.0%(Jiyuan),and the DTPA-Mn concentration significantly increased by 290.3%(Jiyuan)and 73.5%(Zhuzhou),and the DTPA-Fe concentration significantly decreased by 9.5%(Jiyuan)and 12.0%(Zhuzhou),respectively.The order of reducing Cd availability of three passivation materials in two lead smelting sites was cement>Mn-P modified biochar>Mn-P modified rice husk ash,and the order of reducing Pb availability was cement>Mn-P modified biochar>Mn-P modified rice husk ash(Jiyuan)and Mn-P modified biochar>Mn-P modified rice husk ash>cement(Zhuzhou).It was necessary to select suitable passivation materials based on the Cd and Pb pollution characteristics of lead smelting sites to achieve synchronous immobilization of soil Cd and Pb.

passivation materialsCdPbtrace elementsavailability

张欣惠、周青云、许超、武美燕、帅红、张泉、朱奇宏、朱捍华、黄道友

展开 >

湖南师范大学地理科学学院,长沙 410081

中国科学院亚热带农业生态研究所,亚热带农业生态过程重点实验室,中国科学院长沙农业环境观测研究站,长沙 410125

长江大学农学院,湖北荆州 434022

钝化材料 Cd Pb 微量元素 有效性

国家重点研发计划课题国家自然科学基金湖南省技术攻关"揭榜挂帅"项目

2019YFC1803602421770252021NK1040

2024

中国农学通报
中国农学会

中国农学通报

CSTPCD
影响因子:0.891
ISSN:1000-6850
年,卷(期):2024.40(21)
  • 14