中国司法鉴定2024,Issue(4) :10-20.DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1671-2072.2024.04.002

"其他类"司法鉴定管理的困境与改革

The Dilemma and Reform on Forensic Appraisal in the"Other Categories"Management

陈喆
中国司法鉴定2024,Issue(4) :10-20.DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1671-2072.2024.04.002

"其他类"司法鉴定管理的困境与改革

The Dilemma and Reform on Forensic Appraisal in the"Other Categories"Management

陈喆1
扫码查看

作者信息

  • 1. 青岛大学 法学院,山东 青岛 266071
  • 折叠

摘要

目前,在司法行政部门统一管理的"四大类"司法鉴定外,尚有数量庞大的"其他类"司法鉴定."其他类"司法鉴定存在公信力不足、适用混乱、与现有证据规定矛盾和管理与使用缺位等问题.而上位法缺失、司法行政部门管理力量不足、法院的制度掣肘和行业管理收效甚微又使得司法行政部门的统一管理面临困境.为此,要通过统一司法鉴定立法、采取渐进措施推进、强化行业管理力量以及完善司法鉴定管理与使用衔接,以实现"其他类"司法鉴定统一管理的改革目标.

Abstract

At present,besides the forensic appraisal in the"Four Categories"under the management of judicial administrative departments,there are still a large number of forensic appraisal in the"other categories".The forensic appraisal in the"other categories"have many problems such as insufficient credibility,confusion in application,contradictions with existing evidence regulations,and lack of combination of appraisal management and application.The absence of superior laws,insufficient management capabilities of judicial administrative departments,institutional constraints of the courts,and limited effectiveness in industry management have all posed challenges to the unified management of judicial administrative departments.To achieve the reform goal of unified management of forensic appraisal in the"other categories",it is necessary to unify legislation on forensic appraisal,take gradual measures to push the unification of forensic appraisal management,strengthen industry management and improve the connection between forensic appraisal management and application.

关键词

"其他类"司法鉴定/司法鉴定管理/司法行政部门

Key words

forensic appraisal in the"other categories"/management of forensic appraisal/judicial administrative departments

引用本文复制引用

出版年

2024
中国司法鉴定
司法部司法鉴定科学技术研究所

中国司法鉴定

CSTPCD
影响因子:0.485
ISSN:1671-2072
段落导航相关论文