2018～2022年中文期刊发表儿科指南的现状分析
Pediatric guidelines published in Chinese journals from 2018 to 2022:an analysis on current situation
陈以铭 1车刚 2耿一雄 3张宇轩 3赵星媛 3朱娜 3刘思含 4唐玉英 5刘雅莉6
作者信息
- 1. 730000 兰州,兰州大学口腔医学院
- 2. 735100 嘉峪关,嘉峪关市第一人民医院
- 3. 100045 北京,国家儿童医学中心 首都医科大学附属北京儿童医院
- 4. 117004 本溪,沈阳药科大学中药学院
- 5. 730030 兰州,兰州大学第二医院
- 6. 100045 北京,国家儿童医学中心首都医科大学附属北京儿童医院临床流行病学与循证医学中心
- 折叠
摘要
目的 调查分析2018～2022年中文期刊发表儿科指南现状.方法 在万方医药期刊数据库(WanFang Data)、中国知网(CNKI)、中国生物医学文献数据库(CBM)、维普(VIP)数据库中进行检索,检索时限均为2018年1月1日至2022年12月31日.筛选文献、提取资料后,采用BICOMB软件对指南作者信息进行提取和整理、生成作者共现矩阵,使用Ucinet 6.661软件绘制作者社会网络关系可视化图.结果 共纳入儿科指南108部,包括66部循证指南,42部非循证指南.其中西医指南91部(84.3%),中医指南17部(15.7%).指南类型以诊疗类指南(39.8%,43/108)为主,其次为技术类指南(14.8%,16/108)和治疗类指南为主(13.0%,14/108).大多数纳入指南分别由(25.9%,28/108)学组和(20.4%,22/108)专业委员会制订,其次为个人(14.8%,16/108)和学会(13.9%,15/108).制订作者的社会网络关系图显示,共有8个主要研究团体参与了儿科指南的制订.结论 近5年内发表儿科指南数量较为稳定,循证指南年均发表数量显著提高.团体单位参与并主导制订,以学会、学组牵头发表的循证指南占比较高,指南制订工作期望多学科合作进一步加强,尤其重视循证医学/指南方法 学家的参与,以便进一步提高指南质量.
Abstract
Objective To investigate and analyze the current situation of pediatric guidelines published in Chinese journals from 2018 to 2022.Methods The databases of WanFang Data,CNKI,CBM and VIP Database were retrieved from Jan.1,2018 to Dec.31,2022.After screened literature and extracted data,the information of pediatric guideline authors was extracted and organized by using BICOMB software to product author co-occurrence matrixes.A visual graph of authors'social network relationship was plotted by using Ucinet 6.661 software.Results There were totally 108 pediatric guidelines included,including 66 evidence-based guidelines and 42 non-evidence-based guidelines.Among them there were 91(84.3%)guidelines of Western medicine and 17(15.7%)guidelines of traditional Chinese medicine(TCM).The main types of the guidelines were diagnosis and treatment guidelines(39.8%,43/108),followed by technical guidelines(14.8%,16/108)and therapeutical guidelines(13.0%,14/108).Most of the guidelines(25.9,28/108)were developed by societies,followed by professional committees(20.4%,22/108).Academy groups and professional associations were also involved in the formulation of the guidelines,accounting for 14.8%(16/108)and 13.9%(15/108),respectively.The authors'social network relationship graph showed that there were 8 major research groups involved in the development of pediatric guidelines.Conclusion The number of pediatric guidelines published in recent 5 years is stable,but the number of TCM guidelines is less.The annual number of evidence-based guidelines published has increased significantly.There is lack of collaborations between different research groups,and the participation of evidence-based experts is not widespread.In the future,more evidence-based experts should be involved in the formulation of guidelines to further improve the quality of guidelines.
关键词
临床实践指南/儿童/现状分析Key words
Clinical practice guidelines/Children/Status analysis引用本文复制引用
出版年
2024
NETL
NSTL
万方数据