首页|X射线血管造影在肝癌介入TACE术后复发、疗效及肝脏肿瘤灌注减少的评估价值

X射线血管造影在肝癌介入TACE术后复发、疗效及肝脏肿瘤灌注减少的评估价值

Assessment value of X-ray angiography in postoperative recurrence,curative effect and the reduction of the perfusion of liver tumor of interventional TACE for liver cancer

扫码查看
目的:探讨X射线血管造影在肝癌介入经导管动脉化疗栓塞术(TACE)术后复发、疗效及肝脏肿瘤灌注减少的评估价值.方法:选取2015年1月至2020年12月于蚌埠市第三人民医院接受治疗的59例肝癌患者,所有患者术前1周、术后4周均行常规X射线血管造影检查,将获得的影像序列导入装有彩色编码数字减影血管造影(ccDSA)成像技术软件的工作站进行分析,在TACE前后的ccDSA图像上手动定义感兴趣区域(ROI),获得时间强度曲线并从中导出达峰时间(TTP)、受试者工作特征(ROC)曲线下面积(AUC)及最大斜率(MS)等定量灌注参数.通过其计算AUC,分析灌注参数对肝癌TACE术后复发、疗效及肝脏肿瘤灌注减少的评估效能.结果:纳入研究的59例患者根据术后复发定义,术后复发39例,未复发20例,术后复发患者灌注TTP(7.38±1.22)s明显低于未复发患者(9.03±1.01)s,差异有统计学意义(t=5.198,P<0.05),AUC、MS明显低于术后未复发患者,差异有统计学意义(t=10.741、31.499,P<0.05),术后复发和未复发患者术前TTP、AUC及MS比较,差异无统计学意义(P>0.05).根据疗效判定标准,有效35例,无效24例,有效患者术后TTP(9.09±1.08)s明显高于无效患者(7.84±2.07)s,差异有统计学意义(t=3.029,P<0.05),AUC、MS明显高于无效患者,差异有统计学意义(t=3.852、54.366,P<0.05),有效患者和无效患者术前TTP、AUC及MS比较,差异均无统计学意义(P>0.05),有效患者和无效患者术后TTP、AUC及MS均高于术前,两组比较差异有统计学意义(t=3.029、3.852、54.366,P<0.05).根据主观血管造影栓塞端点(SACE)分级标准,Ⅲ级33例,Ⅳ级26例,Ⅲ级和Ⅳ级患者术前TTP、AUC及MS比较,差异无统计学意义(P>0.05),Ⅳ级患者术后TTP、AUC及MS均明显低于Ⅲ级患者,两组比较差异有统计学意义(t=7.697、3.498、58.968,P<0.05).TTP、AUC及MS评估肝癌介入TACE术后复发的灵敏度为66.70%、89.70%和59.00%,特异度为55.00%、55.00%和55.00%,TTP、AUC及MS评估肝癌介入TACE术后复发的AUC分别为0.629(95%CI:0.478~0.779)、0.827(95%CI:0.723~0.931)和0.512(95%CI:0.356~0.667);TTP、AUC及MS评估肝癌介入TACE术后疗效的灵敏度为64.10%、79.50%、61.50%,特异度为55.00%、65.00%和55.00%,TTP、AUC及MS评估肝癌介入TACE术后疗效的AUC分别为0.609(95%CI:0.462~0.756)、0.808(95%CI:0.698~0.918)和0.580(95%CI:0.413~0.747);TTP、AUC及MS评估肝癌介入TACE术后肝脏肿瘤灌注减少的灵敏度为69.20%、82.10%和53.80%,特异度为70.00%、75.00%和55.00%,TTP、AUC及MS评估肝癌介入TACE术后肝脏肿瘤灌注减少的AUC分别为0.745(95%CI:0.613~0.877)、0.842(95%CI:0.724~0.960)和0.507(95%CI:0.360~0.654).结论:X射线血管造影检查后的数据通过ccDSA的定量分析获得的TTP、AUC及MS灌注参数,对肝癌介入TACE术后复发、疗效及肝脏肿瘤灌注减少的评估均具有一定应用价值.
Objective:To investigate the assessment value of X-ray angiography in postoperative recurrence,curative effect and reduction of the perfusion of liver tumor of interventional transarterial chemoembolization(TACE)for liver cancer.Methods:A total of 59 patients with liver cancer who were treated in The Third the People's Hospital of Bengbu from January 2015 to December 2020 were selected.All patients underwent the examination of routine X-ray angiography one week before surgery and four weeks after surgery.The obtained image sequences were imported into the workstation equipped with imaging technology software of color coded digital subtraction angiography(ccDSA)to conduct analysis.The region of interest(ROI)was manually defined on the ccDSA images before and after TACE.And then,the time intensity curve was obtained,and the quantitative perfusion parameters included the time to peak(TTP),area under curve(AUC),maximum slope(MS)were exported from that.The receiver operating characteristics(ROC)curve was drawn,and the area under curve(AUC)of that was calculated to analyze the assessment efficacy of perfusion parameters on the postoperative recurrence,curative effect and reduction of the perfusion of liver tumor of TACE for liver cancer.Results:In the 59 patients who were included in the study,39 cases occurred postoperative recurrence and 20 cases did not occurred postoperative recurrence according to the definition of postoperative recurrence,and the perfusion TTP(7.38±1.22)s of patients with postoperative recurrence was significantly lower than that(9.03±1.01)s of patients without postoperative recurrence,and the difference of that between them was significant(t=5.198,P<0.05).The AUC and MS of patients with postoperative recurrence were significantly lower than those of patients without postoperative recurrence(t=2.868,31.499,P<0.05),respectively.There were not significant differences in TTP,AUC and MS between patients with and without postoperative recurrence before surgery(P>0.05).According to the determination criteria of curative effect,35 cases were effectiveness,and 24 cases were ineffectiveness,and the postoperative TTP(9.09±1.08)s of patients with effectiveness was significantly higher than that(7.84±2.07)s of patients without effectiveness(t=3.029,P<0.05),and AUC and MS of patients with effectiveness were significantly higher than those of patients without ineffectiveness(t=3.852,54.366,P<0.05),and there were not significant differences in preoperative TTP,AUC and MS between patients with and without effectiveness(P>0.05),and the values of TTP,AUC and MS of the group with effectiveness and group without effectiveness after surgery were significantly higher than those before surgery,and the differences of them between two groups were significant(t=3.029,3.852,54.366,P<0.05),respectively.According to the grading criteria of subjective angiographic endpoints(SACE),33 cases were grade Ⅲ,and 26 cases were grade Ⅳ,and there were not significant in TTP,AUC and MS between patients with grade Ⅲ and patients with grade IV(P>0.05).The postoperative TTP,AUC and MS of patients with grade Ⅳ were significantly lower than those of patients with grade Ⅲ(t=7.679,3.498,58.968,P<0.05),respectively.The sensitivities of TTP,AUC and MS were respectively 66.70%,89.70% and 59.00% in assessing postoperative recurrence of interventional TACE for liver cancer,and the specificities of them were respectively 55.00%,55.00% and 55.00%,and the AUC values of them were respectively 0.629(95% CI:0.478-0.779),0.827(95% CI:0.723-0.931)and 0.512(95% CI:0.356-0.667).The sensitivities of TTP,AUC and MS were respectively 64.10%,79.50% and 61.50% in assessing postoperatively curative effect of interventional TACE for liver cancer,and the specificities of them were respectively 55.00%,65.00% and 55.00%,and the AUC values of them were respectively 0.609(95% CI:0.462-0.756),0.808(95% CI:0.698-0.918)and 0.580(95% CI:0.413-0.747).The sensitivities of TTP,AUC and MS were respectively 69.20%,82.10% and 53.80% in assessing the postoperative reduction of the perfusion of liver tumor of interventional TACE for liver cancer,and the specificities of them were respectively 70.00%,75.00% and 55.00%,and the AUC values of them were respectively 0.745(95% CI:0.613-0.877),0.842(95% CI:0.724-0.960)and 0.507(95% CI:0.360-0.654).Conclusion:The TTP,AUC and MS of perfusion parameters that are obtained by ccDSA quantitative analysis for the data after X-ray angiography examination have a certain application value in assessing the postoperative recurrence,curative effect and the reduction of the perfusion of liver tumor of interventional TACE for liver cancer.

X-ray angiographyInterventional transarterial chemoembolization(TACE)for liver cancerPostoperative recurrenceCurative effectReduction of the perfusion of liver tumor

徐苏玲、张耀纲、徐士伟、沈亚迪

展开 >

蚌埠市第三人民医院介入科 蚌埠 233000

X射线血管造影 肝癌介入经导管动脉化疗栓塞术(TACE) 术后复发 疗效 肝脏肿瘤灌注减少

蚌埠市科技创新指导类项目

20210319

2024

中国医学装备
中国医学装备协会

中国医学装备

CSTPCD
影响因子:0.882
ISSN:1672-8270
年,卷(期):2024.21(2)
  • 19