中国政法大学学报2024,Issue(5) :5-19.

论预防性环境公益诉讼中"重大风险"之认定

李义松 黄洁
中国政法大学学报2024,Issue(5) :5-19.

论预防性环境公益诉讼中"重大风险"之认定

李义松 1黄洁2
扫码查看

作者信息

  • 1. 河海大学法学院
  • 2. 江苏省丹阳市人民检察院
  • 折叠

摘要

预防性环境公益诉讼之生态环境重大风险指向未来,具有不确定性,该重大风险的认定及处理既需要科学的评估,又需要在民生经济与生态环保之间进行综合考量和统筹协调.实证研究表明,现行法律框架下的司法裁判对生态环境重大风险之核心概念的理解、对象及判断标准、存在时间、诉因行为之违法性、举证责任及其分配、防控责任配置等问题的判断、认定及处理很不一致.法律供给不足以及诉讼类型、认定方法和主体安排不够科学合理,是生态环境重大风险认定困境的关键成因.立法应在加强法律供给基础上完善预防性环境行政公益诉讼,既尊重环境风险及其防控的行政判断,又对生态环境重大风险之行政管控进行有效督促.重大风险的认定方法及制度设计应遵循生态环境重大风险及其防控的客观规律及社会需求,力求科学合理.重大风险的认定需以法院为主导,同时完善有关行政机关、专家及利害关系人的参与机制.

Abstract

Major environmental risks in the preventive environmental civil public interest litigation are future-oriented and uncertain,whose identification and handling require both scientific assessment and a comprehensive consideration and coordination among people's wellbeing,economic development and ecological conservation.Empirical studies show that from the actual situation of judicial trial,it is found that there are some inconsistency in the judgment,identification and handling of"major risk",in terms of the core concept,the subject and judgment standards,the time of existence,the illegality of the cause of action,burden of proof and,its allocation,and the allocation of responsibilities for prevention and control,among others.Inadequate legal supply,and dislocation of the types of litigation,identification methods and the subject prove to be the key causes of the.difficulties in identifying major environmental risks.In this regard,legislation should focus on improving preventive environmental administrative public interest litigation on the basis of an enhanced legal supply,respecting administrative judgments on environmental risks and their prevention while effectively supervising the administrative management of major environmental risks.The identification method for major risks and the design of the system should adhere to the objective laws and social demands of major environmental risks and their prevention,with an aim to be scientifically sound and reasonable.The identification of major risks should be primarily led by the courts,with the involvement mechanisms of administrative organs,experts and stakeholders being improved.

关键词

预防性环境公益诉讼/生态环境重大风险/风险认定/风险防控

Key words

preventive environmental civil public interest litigation/major environmental risk/risk identification/risk prevention

引用本文复制引用

出版年

2024
中国政法大学学报

中国政法大学学报

CHSSCD
ISSN:
段落导航相关论文