首页|论农村集体成员权与土地财产权分离与联系的制度逻辑

论农村集体成员权与土地财产权分离与联系的制度逻辑

扫码查看
研究目的:基于城乡居民不同历史阶段的经济与社会边界的特征分析,揭示现阶段农村集体成员权和土地财产权分离和联系的制度逻辑,为类型化构造农村土地权利体系提供理论依据.研究方法:社科法学与概念法学相结合的研究方法.研究结果:(1)现阶段乡村封闭的社会边界和开放的经济边界是形成农村集体成员权与土地财产权分离与联系的深层原因.(2)从权利分离来看,此两种权利是法律性质迥然不同的权利,农村集体成员权是团体法上的权利,包括共益权和自益权两部分,土地财产权是个体法上的权利,包括基于身份分配取得的社会保障导向的土地权利和基于价格机制取得的财产经营导向的土地权利.(3)从权利联系来看,此两种权利有着密切的法理联系,农村集体成员权中的共益权和自益权分别与土地财产权中的集体土地所有权和含身份的用益物权之间有着密切的关系.研究结论:农村集体成员权与土地财产权之间存在分离与联系的制度逻辑,可以采用"一般法+特别法"的立法技术进行体系化构造,在《民法典》中构造农村集体成员权和土地财产权的基础法律概念和土地权利关系的一般框架,在《土地管理法》等单行法中规定具体类型土地权利的权利义务、行使规则和救济规则.
Institutional Logic of Separation and Connection between Membership Rights and Land Property Rights of Rural Collectives
The purposes of this study are to reveal the institutional logic of the separation and connection between the membership rights and land property rights of rural collectives in the current stage by analyzing the characteristics of the economic and social boundaries of urban and rural residents in different historical stages,and to provide a theoretical basis for the further construction of rural land rights system.The research method combining sociology of law and conceptualist jurisprudence is employed.The research results show that:1)at the current stage,the closed social boundary and open economic boundary in rural areas are the fundamental reasons for the separation and connection between membership rights and land property rights of rural collectives.2)From the perspective of rights separation,these two types of rights are of fundamentally different legal nature.Membership rights of rural collectives pertain to group law,encompassing collective benefit rights and individual benefit rights.Rural land property rights are rights of individual law,including social security-oriented land property rights based on membership and management-oriented real rights based on price mechanism.3)From the perspective of rights connection,these two kinds of rights have close legal relations.The collective benefit right and individual benefit right in membership rights of rural collectives are closely related to the collective land ownership and usufructuary right with identity,respectively.In conclusion,there is a systematic logic of separation and connection between membership rights and land property rights of rural collectives,which will be systematically proposed by the legislative technology of"general law+special law".The basic legal concepts of membership rights and land property rights of rural collectives and the general framework of land right relations are constructed in the Civil Code.The Land Administration Law and other separate laws stipulate the rights and obligations,exercise rules and relief rules of specific land rights.

rural land policygroup lawproperty lawmembership right"tripartite entitlement system"

徐忠国、卓跃飞、李冠、王雪琪、陈阳

展开 >

宁波大学法学院,浙江 宁波 315211

农村土地制度 团体法 物权法 成员权 "三权分置"

浙江省哲学社会科学规划年度课题国家自然科学基金面上一般项目浙江省自然科学基金青年基金浙江省省属高校基本科研业务费项目

22NDJC070YB42171254LQ22G030001SJWY2022004

2024

中国土地科学
中国土地学会 中国土地勘测规划院

中国土地科学

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:2.396
ISSN:1001-8158
年,卷(期):2024.38(7)