首页|自然资源统一确权登记改革的制度检视与立法完善——以物权登记为视角

自然资源统一确权登记改革的制度检视与立法完善——以物权登记为视角

扫码查看
研究目的:破解登记改革中"重监管轻权益"的制度路径偏离问题,遵循物权法定原则界定自然资源统一确权登记的功能、性质、事项范围及法律效力,为《民法典》中自然资源所有权行使提供程序法上的登记保障.研究方法:规范分析、体系解释.研究结果:(1)现行自然资源登记改革奉行"服务于所有权和监管权"的公私复合目标,但实践中生态优先指引的保护性公法功能居于主导地位,服务于物权行使的登记规则相对粗疏简化.(2)采取"全覆盖"的总登记模式,忽视了自然资源的财产属性而予以无差别登记,导致权利登记与行政调查相混淆.(3)空间整体登记以生态行政监管权为实体权利基础,导致财产法范畴服务于生态空间整体开发流转的登记规则缺位.(4)集体自然资源所有权的登记地位模糊,为实现统一管制要求,集体登记事项被套合于国有单元之内,有违所有权平等保护的物权原则.研究结论:应根据物权行使与限制的二元效力内容,分设自然资源登记的公私目标实现路径,构建保护性公法目标与物权限制的效力关联;增设所有权具体行使主体及授权来源、行使方式等登记事项,采纳自然资源的"可经营性"物权客体限制标准;完善生态空间整体流转下的财产化物权登记规则;登记范围应从对象的全覆盖转向权利类型的全覆盖,遵循所有权平等保护原则赋予集体自然资源所有权登记能力,突出权益登记内容.
Systematic Review and Legislative Improvement of the Reform of Unified Right Confirmation and Registration of Natural Resources—From the Perspective of Property Registration
The purposes of this study are to address the institutional deviation problem of"heavy regulation and weak rights"in the registration reform of natural resources,to follow the principle of legal certainty in property rights to define the functions,nature,scope of items,and legal effects of natural resources unified registration,and to provide procedural legal guarantees for the exercise of natural resources ownership rights in the Civil Code.The research methods include normative analysis and system interpretation.The research results show that 1)the current natural resources registration reform pursues a public-private approach that serves ownership and regulatory rights,and the protective public law function of ecological priority guidance is in a dominant position.2)Under the overall registration mode of full coverage,the property attributes of natural resources are ignored and registered without discrimination,the registration of rights is confused with administrative investigation.3)The legal attribute of space registration unit focuses on control and neglects utilization,and lacks the effect of rights protection in property law.4)The registration status of collective natural resources ownership is vague,and to serve the requirements of unified control,the registration items are contained within the state-owned units,which violates the principle of equal protection of property rights.In conclusion,under the category of real rights registration,the paths to realize the public and private goals of natural resources registration are divided according to the exercise and restriction of real rights,and construct the effective relation between the objective of protective public law and the limitation of real rights.It is necessary to add the registration items such as the specific subject of ownership,the source and the way of exercising the rights,and adopt the profit-making object limitation standard of natural resources.The regulatory attribute of space registration should be stripped away,and the effect of property registration under the overall transfer of ecological space assets in the scope of property law should be reconstructed.The scope of registration should shift from full coverage of registered objects to full coverage of rights types,endow collective natural resources ownership registration capabilities in accordance with the principle of equal ownership protection,and highlight the content of rights and interests registration.

unified right confirmation and registration of natural resourcesnatural resources ownershipproperty rightsecological space registration

韩英夫

展开 >

辽宁大学法学院,辽宁 沈阳 110036

自然资源统一确权登记 自然资源所有权 物权保障 生态空间登记

2024

中国土地科学
中国土地学会 中国土地勘测规划院

中国土地科学

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:2.396
ISSN:1001-8158
年,卷(期):2024.38(11)