首页|制造"诬""间"叙事——北宋与西夏交往交流中的话语调适

制造"诬""间"叙事——北宋与西夏交往交流中的话语调适

Create a Narrative Discourse that Make False Accusation and Discord as "Wu" and "Jian":Speech Adjustment in the Communication between the Northern Song Dynasty and the Xixia Dynasty

扫码查看
北宋与西夏交往交流的叙事话语隐含着重要的文化理念与秩序追求,双方都秉持君、臣纲常这一基本的刚性原则,但是表面的臣属及"君仁臣忠"的理想君臣话语却也很难概观宋夏间复杂的争斗.因此,既能维护君臣关系,又能调适理想与现实冲突的一套"诬""间"叙事话语便应运而生了."诬""间"话语的核心是将责任推向君臣之外的"第三者".北宋朝廷方面常以此来"含容"西夏,西夏方面则常借以推卸责任和维护大宋天子权威.宋夏双方都借由"诬""间"话语来维护"斗而不破"的君臣伦理关系.认真梳理宋夏君臣之间的"诬""间"叙事话语,对于正确认识传统君臣伦理对宋夏关系的影响,中华传统文化对宋夏战争性质、和解模式等的宰制,以及北宋偃武修文国策对宋夏缘边地区边臣与武将的约束都具有重要的意义.
Narrative discourse of the interaction and communication between Northern Song Dynasty and his vassal state Xixia Dynasty implies important cultural ideas and orders.Although both sides obeyed the hierarchical system and behaved according to the role ethics of the emperor and his ministers,but this can hardly avoid the complex struggle among them despite the superficial benevolence of the emperor and the loyalty of the ministers.Therefore,there arose a set of"wu"and"jian"narrative discourse that can not only maintain the relationship between the emperor and the minister,but also adjust the conflict between the ideal and the reality.The core of the"wu"and"jian"narrative discourse is to push the responsibility to the"third party"outside the emperor and ministers.The Northern Song court often used"wu"and"jian"narrative discourse to"contain"the Xixia,while the Xixia regime often used it to evade responsibility and maintain the authority of the emperor of the Song Dynasty.Both sides of Song and Xixia maintained the ethical relationship between"fighting without breaking-up"through"wu"and"jian"narrative discourse.Careful review of the narrative discourse of"wu"and"jian"between the Song emperor and the Xixia ministers is of great significance for the correct understanding of the influence of the tradition of emperors and official ethics on the relationship between Song and Xixia,the control of traditional Chinese culture on the nature of the war and the reconciliation mode of Song and Xixia,and the constraints of the state policy of Yanwu Xiuwen in the Northern Song Dynasty on the border ministers and military generals at the borderland area in between Song and Xixia.

Northern Song DynastyXixia Dynastycommunication and exchangenarrative discourse

何强

展开 >

兰州大学 历史文化学院,甘肃兰州 730020

北宋 西夏 交往交流 叙事话语

国家社会科学基金青年项目甘肃省哲学社会科学规划重点委托项目

22CZS0232023ZDWT07

2024

中央民族大学学报:哲学社会科学版
中央民族大学

中央民族大学学报:哲学社会科学版

CSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:0.635
ISSN:1005-8575
年,卷(期):2024.51(5)