首页|类案类判:道德应当还是法律应当

类案类判:道德应当还是法律应当

扫码查看
类案类判具有法律应当与道德应当的双重属性,将其定位于纯粹的道德应当或法律应当面临诸多困境。因此,我们有必要在理论构造层面构建两者之间的协同实现机制,探求类案类判在司法实践中的实现规程。总体而言,法律应当优先于道德应当是较为现实的选择,也是形式正义的基本要求,但法律应当优先并不当然否定法官道德应当的反思精神。道德应当是实现实质正义必不可少的重要环节,在时势变更、法律修订等特殊情形下,道德应当的地位需优于法律应当。具体而言,在理论构造层面要坚持法律应当优先前提下的道德应当优先的兼顾;在实践层面要坚持道德应当指导下的法律应当制度化推进。
Similar Judgement of Similar Cases:Moraity Should-be or law Should-be
Similar judgement of similar cases has dual attributes of morality should-be and law should-be,positioning it as pure morality or law should-be face many difficulties.Therefore,it is necessary to construct a cooperative realization mechanism between the two in the theoretical structure and explore the realization procedure of the judgment in the judicial practice.Overall,the priority of law over morality should be a more realistic choice and a basic requirement of formal justice.However,the priority of law does not necessa-rily negate the reflective spirit that judges should have in terms of morality.Morality should be an essential link in achieving substantive justice.In special circumstances such as changing circumstances and legal revisions,the status of morality should be superior to that of law.Specifically,at the theoretical construction level,it is necessary to consider giving priority to morality while adhering to the prem-ise that law should be given priority.At the practical level,we must adhere to the promotion of the institutionalization of law should-be guided by morality should-be.

similar judgement of similar casescase guiding systemmorality should-belaw should-beXi Jingping's Thought on the Rule of Law

彭凤莲

展开 >

安庆师范大学(安徽安庆 246011)

类案类判 案例指导制度 道德应当 法律应当 习近平法治思想

2022年度法治建设与法学理论研究部级重点项目

22SFB200

2024

中州学刊
河南省社会科学院

中州学刊

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:0.854
ISSN:1003-0751
年,卷(期):2024.(3)
  • 38