首页|"杜公遗响"与"义山轻薄":桐城派李商隐诗歌批评的两面性

"杜公遗响"与"义山轻薄":桐城派李商隐诗歌批评的两面性

扫码查看
桐城派对李商隐诗歌的评价,既有肯定的一面,也有批评的一面。桐城派诗人称李诗为杜诗"嗣响",指其句法、章法效法杜诗,神韵亦能与之媲美。李诗诸体中,桐城派诗人最推崇其中的七律。因为李商隐在杜甫、王维之后另开一派,融合杜之阳刚与王之阴柔,达到刚柔相济的美学境界。桐城派受程朱理学的影响,诗文追求朴实无华的本色之美,而李诗用藻饰之词写男女艳情,故而批评者较多,唯曾国藩追求"怡悦"之审美效果而欣赏李诗。李诗涉及男女之情,因此托旨遥深,桐城派不满其迂晦深隐、浓艳轻利、浮泛支离。桐城派对李商隐诗歌的评价,折射出挽救其时诗坛之弊的用心。
"The Legacy of Du Du"and"The Farivous Character of Yishan":The Two Sides of Li Shangyin's Poetry Criticism in the Tongcheng School
The evaluation of Li Shangyin's poetry by the Tongcheng School had both positive and critical aspects.The poets of the Tongcheng School referred to Li Shangyin's poetry as a descendant of Du Fu's poetry for the syntax and structure of the former modeled after the latter,and the charm of the former can also be comparable to the latter.Among the various genres of Li Shangyin's poetry,Tongcheng poets highly admired his Seven Rhymes.Li Shangyin opened up another path after Du Fu and Wang Wei,blending the mas-culine beauty of Du Fu's poetry with the feminine beauty of Wang Wei's poetry,achieving an aesthetic realm of combining hardness and softness.The Tongcheng School was influenced by the"Cheng-Zhu Neo Confucianism",and their poetry and prose pursued the natural beauty of simplicity,while Li Shangyin's poetry used embellishment to depict the romance between men and women,resulting in more criticism.Only Zeng Guofan appreciated Li Shangyin's poetry for pursuing the aesthetic effect of"pleasure".Li Shangyin's poetry had much sustenance because it involved the relationship between men and women.The Tongcheng School was dissatisfied with the convoluted and secretive,rich and frivolous,and fragmented nature of his poetry.The evaluation of Li Shangyin's poetry by the Tongcheng School reflected their desire to save the drawbacks of the poetry industry at that time.

the Tongcheng SchoolLi ShangyinDu Fudecorateobscure

潘务正

展开 >

安徽师范大学中国诗学研究中心(安徽芜湖 241002)

桐城派 李商隐 杜甫 藻饰 僻晦

安徽省高等学校协同创新项目

GXXT-2020-029

2024

中州学刊
河南省社会科学院

中州学刊

CSTPCDCSSCICHSSCD北大核心
影响因子:0.854
ISSN:1003-0751
年,卷(期):2024.(4)
  • 30